Preps Pizzeria

Great crispy crust. Good cheese. Great boardwalk slice.

Very good slice.

The sauce has a VERY similar flavor to that of Manco & Manco. However, the cheese didn’t quite hit the mark as well, but with that being said, it’s still a great slice I’d recommend. Great crisp too.

good ass crust

Very cheesy. Bland. Too saucy. Doughy. No slices.

I can’t give it a higher score than Phil’s but it is 110% better than Manco and Manco. Good crust, cheese is melted nicely, great sauce to cheese ratio.

Very crispy under crust, love that. Sauce is sweet, but solid. Nothing to write home about the cheese, it’s decent though. This pizza bites really well and is extremely crushable. Cool logo too, a classic right behind Mack&Manco..

Not very good. Stick with the original, Mack & Manco. Nothing special. Think crust felt like elios pizza. Sauce bland. Good thing was they have a coupon: 2 slices and a small drink for $5. You essentially get the drink for free as slices are $2.50. the fact that the public has an average score is the high sevens is an actual disgrace.

Very fully of flavor, creamy cheese, great crisp. One of my new found favorites

That crunchy crust. Manco style wit da sauce on top, but wayyyy better.

Solid boardwalk slice.

Great pie. Thin crunchy crust, good sauce to cheese ratio, slightly too greasy. Very underrated

Sauce tastes canned, not enough cheese or sauce on pizza.

Good stuff

Thin, which I like. A little undercooked. Too much flop. Not very greasy. Bland and too salty. Good boardwalk pizza. Ate 5 slices.

After eating a slice from every pizza place on the boardwalk in the manner of two hours, the one place I would go back to is Prep’s. Better than the overrated Manco & Manco’s but they don’t get the recognition for it. Prep’s is very clean compared to the other pizza places on the boardwalk and had a great slice to represent themselves. I get why they are still in existence since 1965. P.S. watch for the seagulls when carrying food. Those things are savages and almost took me out!

Great tasting sauce and tang. Crunchy but a little too much sauce.