Very crispy under crust, love that. Sauce is sweet, but solid. Nothing to write home about the cheese, it’s decent though. This pizza bites really well and is extremely crushable. Cool logo too, a classic right behind Mack&Manco..
aj.labella6/7/21, 6:25 p.m.
What manco and manco lacks in texture and crisp, Preps makes up for it. However; cheese and sauce aren't as flavorful. Complete toss up between the two pies.
michael.cocosis6/6/21, 4:03 p.m.
Sauce shines here. So bold. The cheese not so much. Cooked perfect, but it's also reheated. I feel like it could get in the 8s fresh.
christine.hammett6/6/21, 4:02 p.m.
Great slice! Very delicious, sweet sauce. Good amount of cheese and crisp. Loved it!
chad.etschman4/17/21, 7:24 p.m.
Good crisp bubbly crust. Nice flavor. Excellent boardwalk pizza.
jersey.gio4/9/21, 1:18 a.m.
The Saucy Boardwalk Slice. Boardwalk-styled Pizza. ...Taste Analysis... Sauce: smokey. Cheese: bland. Crust: perfectly fluffy yet chalky. An extra sauce lover’s slice. A Smokey taste to the sauce, very distinguished. Prep’s Pizza is a solid alternative for those wanting a boardwalk-styled pizza with tangy sauce similar to Manco & Manco but without waiting in the long-lines of shoobies (out-of-state crowds). Prep’s at its best is in the low 7’s; Which is a fine slice, my 6.8 reflects my slice on the day of this review.
shawn.bauer4/7/21, 6:16 p.m.
Best OCNJ boardwalk pizza. Very similar to the staple Monaco's, just better in my opinion.
dade.walker9/14/20, 10:58 p.m.
The sauce has a VERY similar flavor to that of Manco & Manco. However, the cheese didn’t quite hit the mark as well, but with that being said, it’s still a great slice I’d recommend. Great crisp too.
ajamesiii7/23/20, 6:29 p.m.
I can’t give it a higher score than Phil’s but it is 110% better than Manco and Manco. Good crust, cheese is melted nicely, great sauce to cheese ratio.