Preps Pizzeria & Dairy Bar

Really good. Great crust, crispy, cheese and sauce is tasty. Just a bit floppy. Great shore pizza.

Really greasy not much flavor in sauce, but for on board walk not terrible

hmmm. i feel like i also remember this being better. the cheese gives off amusement park slice. good crisp bite, but something isn’t clicking. three brothers over this for sure

Walked by hundreds of times. Glad I finally stopped!!!

No picture - forgot to take one

Sauce was great and cheese had very good flavor.

The pizza dudeguy says the crust isn’t the crunchiest

Sauce and cheese are great. Crust ihas just the right crunch. Great pie.

Great Boardwalk Pizza. Sweet Sauce $4.50 a slice

Phenomenal for boardwalk pizza

Wow

This was an embarrassment for Preps. I don’t know if it was because we had it delivered and it wasn’t super hot. But the pizza was grossly floppy, I couldn’t even fold it and it was just a greasy bland mess.

Banger pizza! When I came in here and asked about the rival, the air turned stale. Manco and manco was closed so we couldn’t try preps famed rival, but very good pizza here none the less. Preps is easily an 8-8.3 type of pie and it certainly gave me ice hockey rink pizza or boardwalk pizza vibes.

0 flop. perfect undercarriage. perfect taste.

As good as Manco and manko’s pizza

Best pizza on OC boardwalk

Excellent pizza. Crispy undercarriage! Pies better than Dave got. Better than manco. Fraction below Moonlite.

Good Slice, much improved since Pres reviewed it. Little to no flop and a crunch on every bite.