Primo Pizza

Alright Franky, back up in the St Augustine/Jacksonville area.....good crisp, no flop, a great Sunday afternoon, large pie and football all day pizza. 7.6, thats a review

By far the best pizza in the area!

Great pie

Im about to rate Primo Pizza by Nocatee. Ponte Vedra St Aug. I had a taste last week and it had me question who the #1 again. 7.3. Undercooked lucky to break 7. Im sure the one I had last week was a higher 7 possibly 8s. Not today. I will rescore within the month not sure if this was just a miss.

Best pie in PV. Nice and thin.

Great crisp not greasy good flavor to the sauce

Best pizza in Jacksonville. Sauce is delicious, perfect amount of cheese, no flop, can’t say enough good things about this pizza.

Great crisp, no flop, sauce is shy but better on the Sicilian. Solid spot go here

Pretty good. They don’t skimp on topping and they are legit New Yorkers. Very refreshing here in Stepford.

Decent greasy neighborhood slice… but the Sicilian slice scores in the mid 8s for me. Order the square slice!!!

Awesome garlic knots! Great sauce and wings. Would be higher if pizza was a little crispier. But it was awesome! Highly recommend

This is the best New York style pizza you’ll find around. Made by a genuine New York family. Nice flop crisscross none of that cornmeal dust all over it perfect cheese good sauce can’t ask for a better slice in this area

Watery cheap tasting sauce. Too much cheese and very doughy. Pizza was also underdone which didn’t help the cause. Finally, deducting a point for the shitty customer service.

Delicious! Crisp! Crunch! If I was local this would be my go-to Staff was really cool

Minimum flop, good undercarriage, nice thin and crispy, good taste ! Definitely a good pie !

Decent NY style slice for the area!

Great crisp, great taste. Had a slice that was sitting but they put it back in the oven for a minute. If it was fresh, probably higher. Definitely would recommend.

Absolutely best pizza in the area and it isn’t close. Perfect Football pizza! Light and crispy crust, sauce has great balance, not too sweet. Tried several different options on toppings but the cheese is all you need. Gold standard.

Good one here. Cheese quality is good. Extra flop. Sicilian was great!

One bite; everyone knows the rules! This pie is delicious! Certainly the best I’ve had in NE Florida! Good sauce to cheese ratio - I like to be able to taste the sauce in each bite. Crust was outrageously good! Nice under carriage with a little bend to it. Edge crust has great crunch! My dog, Moo, gave his Moo Review and he too, thought it was delicious. So good sauce, cheese, and crust. We give it an 8.1. No rookie score here. It’s great pizza. Good job Primo team!

Great pie, sauce, ingredients and crust was amazing. Most authentic NY slice I’ve had in Jax