Best Pepperoni Sicilian Slice I’ve had. 8.9 for sure. Vodka Slice 7.9 Margarita 8.4
Order now on Slice
Order Prince Street Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
kreg.franco5/29/23, 11:57 p.m.
No doubt high quality pizza, but I wouldn’t wait alone again on another 20+ minute line in the sun lol
peter.mitchell5/19/23, 2:10 a.m.
Great 4 cheese slice. Basil is an excellent role player here. Crust tastes like buttery goodness. Some garlic on this would take it to the next level.
sam.kahane5/7/23, 11:01 p.m.
Probably the best square around. Regular was very solid and spicy vodka was good, but definitely has heat. Stop across the street for some Brooklyn blackout cake dessert at Little Cupcake Bakeshop
emma.sluiter4/29/23, 2:16 a.m.
My favorite pizza in NY so far! The “Naughty” had amazing flavor, crunch and spice. Little pockets of sauce and cheese. This “Soho Square” will captivate your tastebuds. 8.9/10. That is all.
harry110514/27/23, 6:40 p.m.
The sauce was great, but too doughy for a +8, surprised with Dave’s score. If hungry great to have in neighbourhood, but wouldn’t be traveling to get this one
aj.labella4/15/23, 4:26 a.m.
Quality of the picture doesn't do this pizza any justice. One of the rare cases where the square Sicilian is better than traditional circle. Circle is mid and nothing special. Square has quality sauce with some kick to it. Crispy. Pepperoni is very good with some kick too. Would be even better if I got fresh full pies rather than slices.
atomnewell4/13/23, 8:03 p.m.
This pizza is phenomenal. They need to bottle their sauce up and sell it immediately.
1 view•1 like
mickydeez4/5/23, 7:06 p.m.
I don’t doubt that the spicy ronj slice is in 8 plus territory, but the margarita, despite being very good, was not quite in that range
whatispizza54/2/23, 6:22 p.m.
There’s only some places you make the trip at 10 am to go to. This is one. The spicy roni here. An excellent square. High 8’s for New York relativity score. Only issue is the drip with spicy red sauce utterly oozing from this number.
pizzavore3/23/23, 11:57 p.m.
I got myself a Spicy Spring Pepperoni slice, as one does at Prince Street Pizza. It was a bit harder than I would have liked, no soft chew to the crust. Could have been fashioned as a weapon if I weren’t quite so hungry. Lot of oil but to be expected. Couldn’t help but think there’s less pepperoni than the place got famous for. Nice cheese, little heat flavor. Was very good but didn’t live up to hype or expectation. Happy to cross a big one off the list
davin.moskal3/12/23, 5:52 a.m.
Was really hoping for a little more out of this legendary spot but overall still good. The sauce was overwhelmingly sweet so interesting
jacob.wolak3/5/23, 1:29 a.m.
One of the best pizzas I've had so far. Both the spicy vodka and pepporoni were really good. I'd give 10/10 but detriot style and lots of cheese isn't a thing.
christian.bowe3/2/23, 11:19 p.m.
Very nice square slice. Not the biggest fan of spicy pepperoni but it was still very good. P.s $12 for two slices..
tbocchino942/27/23, 5:07 p.m.
Didn’t get a cheese I wanted to get the slice this place is known for. Given all circumstances this is in the 9’s for what it is. The crust was crunchy yet the rest of the pie was soft the cheese wasn’t overwhelming and the sauce was great with that extra kick. Pepperoni to top it all off this was a top 2 specialty slice for me
khakijorts2/11/23, 2:40 a.m.
Not bad. Crust and pepperonis are great, but sauce is way too sweet and suffers from lack of flavor outside of pepperonis. Far from the best pizza in NYC, there are places that are far more deserving of the hype like joes or John’s