First review, great slice & the scullion pepperoni was even better, big queues but move quick.
Order now on Slice
Order Prince Street Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
curtis.kruger1/11/23, 5:04 p.m.
Review is on my first and only slice of New York pizza so my review might be skewed. One of my reasons for traveling to New York was to enjoy a slice of pizza and this place was recommended. I was not disappointed. Awesome compared to my home town. If every pizza place is as good as this place, I need to move, lol. Thanks El Pres !!
keith.hoover1/4/23, 2:35 p.m.
Had to try it! This one was disappointing! Adriennes Pizza Bar has a similar style pizza that Dave gave a low score to and Prince St is not even close to that one. I think Adrienne’s is much much better! Definitely not worth the wait!
jmpizza2221/3/23, 5:34 p.m.
this pepperoni square slice was very tasty and had good crunch for a thicker slice. the pizza was slightly on the greasy side but to be expected with the large amount of crispy delish pepps. very nice square pepp pizza for a NY lunch
brian.boothe12/30/22, 9:19 a.m.
Man the square slice was freaking fantastic this was my first new york pizza slice and I hate to say but its much better than CA.
dylan.greenwood12/28/22, 8:47 p.m.
Above Average slice of pizza. A bit overhyped and crowded this piece could have been a lot crispier and didn’t feel the love from the people working there. Still good just not worth the hype around it.
lane.estes12/17/22, 5:51 p.m.
Vodka sauce pizza was really good, but the pepperoni was even better and I’m not a huge pepperoni fan at all!
joe.lawson311/29/22, 11:20 p.m.
The spicy pepperoni was on another level! One of the best New York has to offer!
artie.mase11/16/22, 5:52 p.m.
Good crisp, tasty sauce, slight flop on the end. Overall, a very good slice.
alec.vichio11/15/22, 11:30 p.m.
Spicy pepperoni square slice is a true 9.0. One of the best slices in NY. The cheese slice was a solid 8.6 but definitely get the square. This and Luigi’s are the best 2 in NYC
johnm11/14/22, 4:03 p.m.
Crunchy n crispy crust, semi sweet sauce almost creamy, perfect cheese ratio. Don’t know how you can make a better pizza
joey.stipek11/13/22, 8:51 p.m.
Spicy and chewy. Right amount of heat on the pepperoni slice. Long wait and a pricy slice but ultimately worth it.
jose.regal11/13/22, 4:02 a.m.
Tasty NYC slice. Crust soft but a little crunch, just enough cheese-regular slice sauce was solid but could have had better balance of sweet/tang but the Sicilian roni was one of the best I’ve had-great zing. Worth the wait of half hour.
westcoastcheese11/2/22, 4:25 p.m.
The reviews are all spot on. Everything from the sauce, the dough, the undercarriage, and the cheese/sauce ratio is amazing. I could eat it everyday forever.
gimmesomepie10/31/22, 12:55 a.m.
This upside down might be the best slice in NY. Normal cheese was great too
jake.vardaro10/29/22, 5:55 p.m.
Other then a little flop nothing could’ve been better. The pepperoni is the greatest pizza ive ever tasted