Overhyped but still pretty good. Loving the lack of any kind of line (thank you, COVID, for clearing out the tourists). This place will always be my childhood Ray’s for me, it’s definitely jarring to have paid $5 for this slice, still enjoyed it. Especially liked the heat in the pepperoni and sauce.
Order now on Slice
Order Prince Street Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
ben-dover59/9/23, 1:43 a.m.
Square slices are easily the best I’ve ever had in my life. Perfectly cooked and packs big flavor. A must try spot for anyone that likes squares! Regular NY slice probably an 8.0ish.
pizzacato9/7/23, 2:08 a.m.
Always a long line, which has prevented me and my wife from checking it out, but it moves fast so we hopped on. Pretty much worth the hype. Incredibly solid, reminded me a lot of Joe’s.
sean.newsome19/1/23, 2:18 p.m.
Totally overrated. Nothing more than your typical average NYC slice.
popzeus8/29/23, 3:34 a.m.
The upside down was to die for and the pepperoni was excellent as well.
nblack888/23/23, 3:18 a.m.
A classic favorite deserves a visit and rescore every time. This one did not disappoint. Previous squares resulted in some overdone bites that were too charred and dry. This was the perfect amount of crisp and fluffy crust. Spicy pepps were on point as always. Had me regretting only ordering 1 slice.
lil_meatball8/16/23, 3:13 a.m.
Was an 8.5 before I tried the pepperoni slice, personally pepperoni is not my thing but this was amazing
tony.roni8/12/23, 10:38 p.m.
They wouldn’t put that much pepperoni on the pizza unless it was fantastic. All pro OLineman.
canderson1057/21/23, 8:53 p.m.
Tried the Pepperoni and Spicy Vodka. Neither were reheated and weren’t served super hot. Dough was a bit dense and I would have preferred more sauce on both, but flavor was good overall.
pizzadahut9547/20/23, 7:11 p.m.
I got the pepperoni Sicilian. The sauce and pepperoni were great. The pep was very greasy and spicy. It was crunchy and hot when given to me. There could of been alittle more cheese. Overall great slice
shim.shim7/20/23, 4:46 a.m.
Bro bro. Literally idk. Fuck me. Shit making my stomach growl like a bitch. Oily ass pizza. Apparently order their vodka slice. Also portnoy rated this pizza a 8.6, but none of the workers even know who is. On top of that place is dirty, no wonder my stomachs hurting.
i_forking_eat7/17/23, 10:10 p.m.
Hands down in my opinion, the best square pepperoni in New York. Everything about the dough, sauce and the insane amount of pepperoni all work In perfect harmony. Too bad it takes me over an hour to get into the city from Queens or else I would be here all the time.
jgleonard7/17/23, 5:05 a.m.
Get the spicy pep. I know it’s square and you’re in NYC… do it. It’s the best pizza I’ve ever had. I come back every couple years to check on this opinion… it’s ridiculously good.
4 views•0 likes