Prince Street Pizza

Cheese 8.4 easy. Pepperoni square 6.2 wasn’t hot.

Sauce fire, pep was much to be desired

dont get the hype

Wrong shape, great slice

Tried the classic slice and famous pepperoni square slice. I preferred the cheese, but pepperoni wasn’t too far off. No complaints from me.

tasty sauce super floppy but good crust

Excellent New York City Pizza definitely worth the hype and the wait

Stevie slice on a mini nyc pizza tour. Joes was first stop and it was so good. Prince is second stop and I was figuring it couldn’t hold up to Joes. I must say it was a very good slice . A different taste than joes , but I liked the sauce and they made it crunchy for me so I give high remarks to the crust. Overall, a decent balance, maybe a little more cheese than I like. Still an excellent slice .

Vodka pie is a winner

Tried 3 kinds of slices and will average the scores. Plain had too much cheese not cooked enough and too doughy (7.3), vodka pepperoni square super tasty but dough a bit slimy but better when toasted up at home (7.5), and margarita was the best with the sweet sauce and much better cooked and crispy (8.3). Took my daughters and we had a nice time.

It’s my favorite pizza in the world I can’t even get a different slice because the vodka transports me to a different place. Not sure how they do it so consistently but it’s the best.

tangy sauce, very nice helping. crispy with low flop. overall a great slice

Best special pie ever

I was a bit disappointed in my experience here after previously loving what I had at PSP at their spot in LA. The pepp wasn’t that spicy and not all that much on my slice, and the cheese was just…fine. Maybe I set the bar too high, but they didn’t come close to meeting it this time. I’ll still give them the benefit of the doubt and say it was a one off. This time.

Original prince pie. Taste was very good - good sauce and good cheese but floppy as can be. Crispy crust and would eat again - didn’t get to try the square slices which it looks like everyone was raving about!

This is elite pizza. The circle is a little cheesy and greasy for my personal taste but some love that. It’s perfect if that’s why you’re into. Well done and crispy and cheese has flair. Would give it a 8.1. The squares steal the show. Pepperoni has some kick. The sauce is pretty good. Could use a little more robustness but still very good. The crust is actually perfect even though it’s a bit thicker. Char and crisp with every bite. 9.4 on square. Gonna weight total score a little more towards square since I think that’s what they’re known for.

Very quick to get the food and steaming when it came out. Dough was spectacular with under carriage to die for.

Spicy spring fresh out of the oven was special. Amazing crisp and chew at the same time. Pepperoni cups were high quality, not very spicy. Will be back