Prince Street Pizza

Fkn delicious!

Really wanted to love this place. Normal cheese slice was really nothing to write home about. The square slice which I believe was the “naughty pie” was excellent. I also love the fact you can ask for your slice extra crispy. In my opinion not worth a long wait, but if traffic is light I’d recommend the square slice Ny slice 7.7 Square slice 8.6

Crust: 7/10 Cheese: 9/10 Sauce: 9/10

I really love this place, it’s old school, it feels like Brooklyn in there, and it’s not pretentious like L’industrie. Their squares are worth the trip, but there’s better pizzas in New York.

Standard gluten crust review. This was a great square slice of pizza. Sauce, crust, toppings were all fantastic.

Vodka Sauce is so much better than the four cheese.

Excellent even when slightly cold

solid

Didn’t have plain slices so had to get the “fancy margherita”. Not the freshest but a good slice

I tried the spicy vodka square and it was full of flavor. The dough was good and each bite was a little crispy. Overall more doughy in texture, in a good way. Great balance and I highly recommend!

Not my style of pizza but speaks for itself- delicious

Incredible slice. Crispy, and the sauce tasted phenomenal. Didn’t get a pic, so here’s my dawg

I haven’t had the time to explore all of New York City’s iconic pizza staples and legends yet, but Prince Street always has it going on and serves very good pizza.

Great pizza with a sweeter sauce and Great tasting cheese. Lacking a good undercarriage though.

Seems like it really varies based on when you go, but everything we tried was great. Personally my second favorite pizza in NYC and in general. Reasonably priced, and incredibly good. Not overly floppy, great flavor, a lot of variety. The regular slice was my favorite, but the sicilian were solid as well.