Beautiful chewy crust with a crisp end, perfectly tangy sauce, and fresh cheese. I defy you to find a better grandma
d-pizza10/18/20, 8:18 p.m.
Score applies equally to the plain slice and the square. Totally different slices. Square has a savory delicious sauce, with light, fluffy, crunchy and chewy crust. Plain has sweet, clean sauce and really good crisp. Just a really good plain slice.
andrew.krachie10/16/20, 6:33 p.m.
Just the right amount of spice, crispy bottom, crispy pepperoni that filled up with oil. Really solid
theripizzaguy10/15/20, 9:10 p.m.
Loaded up on pepperoni which is very crispy and make the slice delicious. Crust is great and light on the cheese which I actually like
cameron.surtel10/15/20, 9:09 p.m.
Perfect crust, nice amount of sauce and love the tons of pepperoni. Great slice!
thechowfather10/3/20, 2:48 p.m.
Spicy Spring Slice. Fra diavolo sauce, spicy pepperoni and fresh mozzarella. I’m a standard cheese pie guy but this is the proper play at Prince Street. Worth the wait.
mike.peterson99/14/20, 1:03 a.m.
A refreshing change from a NY slice. Spicy,sweet, & you have to order the with the Roni. 😎
eric.carey28/14/20, 4:29 p.m.
Wasn’t all that impressed. Good slice, maybe overhyped in my opinion. A friend I was with said that the pepperoni wasn’t as crispy as it usually is, which if it were nice and caramelized I’m sure the score would improve. The other margarita slice was meh, and the sauce slice was pretty good.
colin.kiefer8/14/20, 4:03 p.m.
Great slice really fresh really great sauce and cheese and crisp
jcaputo328/6/20, 3:18 a.m.
It’s so funny to see how many people are hypnotized by this mediocre pizza. This score is based off a 6.8 for the regular and a 6.4 for the “famous” pepperoni Sicilian. Firstly, the pepperoni slice is beyond overrated. It wasn’t crunchy, it was over salted, super greasy, and the sauce tasted like lunchables sauce. The pepperoni was undercooked and rubbery. Sicilian needs to be fluffy on the inside and crunchy on the bottom and on the crust. That’s what makes a Sicilian great. The regular slice was a typical football pizza. It was too thick and doughy, not enough crunch and very greasy. WAKE UP PEOPLE IT AINT THAT GOOD!!!!!
ryanloewy7/31/20, 7:50 p.m.
This is some good pizza Frank. Good crisp, great marinara, cheese was on point. Dough was airy and delicious. A bit greasy, but overall this a must go to if you’re on the tour de force for great pizza. That’s a fuckin review Franklyn!!!
chefcobb7/22/20, 11:25 p.m.
Yes, the pepp square is amazing. Not my style, but the dough and crust are fantastic. As everyone says, the pepperoni steals the show here.
jtm27277/12/20, 8:31 p.m.
Overhyped but still pretty good. Loving the lack of any kind of line (thank you, COVID, for clearing out the tourists). This place will always be my childhood Ray’s for me, it’s definitely jarring to have paid $5 for this slice, still enjoyed it. Especially liked the heat in the pepperoni and sauce.
enrico.incarnati7/10/20, 9:25 p.m.
Best Pepperoni Sicilian Slice I’ve had. 8.9 for sure. Vodka Slice 7.9 Margarita 8.4