Prince Street Pizza

Prince St pep square is the proper gold medal slice. Excellent taste, light fluffy dough but way too greasy. The peps were like little grease grenades rolling off. Needed it to be more fresh so it was hotter and the grease couldn’t settle. *BONUS SCORE* Vodka Slice - 8.1

Little greasy but awesome for this style of pie.

Sauce and pepperonis were BOMB, I wanted more cheese action

Too greasy

The spicy spring Sicilian lives up to the hype. Somehow they mastered a super crisp undercarriage but still maintained a chewy doughy center. The sauce was on point and there was no shortage of crisped pepperoni cups in every bite. Doesn’t get much better than this.

Best overall slice in the city. Easy. A 9.4 after dark when the slices are flying. On the oiler side but only cos that cheese sings.

Really tasty Sicilian slice. Really crunchy crust and some of the crispiest pepperonis you will find!

8.7 on the pepperoni square

Sauce - 68/100 Cheese - 96/100 Crust - 80/100 Mouthfeel - 60/100

Minimal flop. Solid undercarriage. Sauce to cheese ratio was perfect. Overall great slice.

Absolute fire for a pep slice

Probably the most overrated pizza I’ve ever had solid slice but definitely could find better pizza around the corner in NYC definitely not worth the try

It’s good pizza but it’s far too expensive and the cheese falls off the slice

Didn’t enjoy the Sicilian as much as the regular but these slices are top notch. Sauce is what makes the pizza here, it’s a must try for any pizza lover. You can’t tell me it’s below an 8.