yerrr14/24/20, 5:36 p.m.
Very good square. Love the cheese to dough & crust ratio. Sauce is awesome & tangy. A lot of pepperoni, had to take some off, but great pizza!
gabriel.matos24/20/20, 5:39 p.m.
Got the Marinara. Very sauce and the sauce has a zing to it. Slight spice. Very good one of the best Sicilian slices I had.
avery.4/18/20, 7:52 p.m.
Could be a little high but some the best pepperonis I’ve had in my day. I’ve never met a pepperoni that doesn’t like taking a bath in this much sauce
greg.keely4/1/20, 10:18 p.m.
Yeah I know this place is famous for their pepperoni squares but this review is for their regular slice. Their regular slice is great. Delicious sauce and lots of it. Nothing bad about this at all.
highlytales3/26/20, 7:20 p.m.
Greese took me out but pepperonis amd taste were on point the standard for a new york square is definitely Prince St.
thepizzaexpeditionist3/11/20, 6:30 p.m.
Top 5 best slice in NYC. The crust is the best I’ve ever had. Hands down.
kevlarltd2/26/20, 6:12 p.m.
Pizza -No flop but a ton of grease from the pepperoni. A handful of napkins were wasted on the pizza slices. - Cheese to Sauce: pretty even in terms of coverage but you will notice that there isn't much of both. The amount of dough and the amount ( and spiciness ) of the pepperoni used set the tone. The slices do satisfy you. You are getting what you paid for but not more. -Taste: Very good slice, get the spicy pepperoni Sicilian slice x 2. With the nice charcoal on the bottom , too much of the bread (while delicious) but not enough cheese and sauce will satisfy your cheese cravings. Cannot skimp out on the premium ingredients when you are charging $5.20 ( including tax) per slice. $10.40 total ( two of the spicy pepperoni silician slices) out the door. Worth going to say that you have been there but not worth a repeat trip.
bkpizza1602/23/20, 10:34 p.m.
It’s all about the Spicy Spring!! Believe the hype. The regular slice is underwhelming that would be a 7.2.
steve.evans22/23/20, 3:43 a.m.
Concavity of the roni’s is something only car nerds hope to achieve. Perfect crunch on the crust. Sauce on point.
cellobello2/21/20, 9:08 p.m.
The regular slice is above average but if you come to Prince St Pizza, you’re coming for a Pepperoni Square! So I’ll leave a rating for that.
emily.nickinello2/16/20, 4:26 a.m.
The only thing (that we know was unavoidable) was wishing they had had somewhere to sit to enjoy our pizza. It was delicious though!
pizzageneral2/1/20, 10:48 p.m.
Had this Pizza years ago.. blew my mind then.. thought Dave would have gone over 9 for sure.. when he didn’t.. I made it a must try when I was here.. I honestly believe he has this one wrong.. the sauce is a spicy marinara and a easy 8.9 on its own..cheese 8.4, crust 9.4 & the overall construction was 9.0.. waited on line for 20 minutes to order a slice.. if you go the only one worth getting is the pepperoni square.. enjoy??v