From the One Bite Fest, come for the pepperoni square. I far prefer round, but that's not what you get when you come here: go square.
Nice sauce on top square, tangy sauce, excellent cup and char pepperoni, slice reheats well, got the whole pilowy yet crunch thing going on in the interior vs. exterior.
Prince Street and Made In New York make a near identical Square. There's a whole controversy around that I forgot the details of but both make a great square.
Yes, you can't eat it everyday unless you don't care and pig out everyday, because it's greasy. But you buy this slice to fucking enjoy it.