Prince Street Pizza

Solid fucking slice. Great flavor. Thicker crust but it's crisp and soft at the same time. Melts in your mouth. Slight kick to the sauce with a great flavor. Cheese isn't stringy but thick and great quality.

Best plain slice I’ve had so far, very tasty cheese! 😋

Solid pizza! Slightly dough-y & could have been crisped a little more, but delicious!

Spicy spring is where its at 💯

Classic square pizza always a great choice.

Great kick to it and pepperonis were great

Good slice. Super busy. No where to sit.

You have to get the pepperoni to to have tried their best. Plain Cheese is good but not like the pepperoni

Spicy Spring. Excellent spicy sauce and pepperoni. Slightly lower than Spumoni Gardens in the square slice game, but still really good.

Yumm

Possibly the best sauce I have ever eaten on a pizza. Crust was a little thick for me or definitely in the 9’s. 🍕#pizzagods

Regular slice not pepperoni score Frankie

Very good square. Love the cheese to dough & crust ratio. Sauce is awesome & tangy. A lot of pepperoni, had to take some off, but great pizza!

Got the Marinara. Very sauce and the sauce has a zing to it. Slight spice. Very good one of the best Sicilian slices I had.

Could be a little high but some the best pepperonis I’ve had in my day. I’ve never met a pepperoni that doesn’t like taking a bath in this much sauce

Yeah I know this place is famous for their pepperoni squares but this review is for their regular slice. Their regular slice is great. Delicious sauce and lots of it. Nothing bad about this at all.

Greese took me out but pepperonis amd taste were on point the standard for a new york square is definitely Prince St.

Top 5 best slice in NYC. The crust is the best I’ve ever had. Hands down.

Come hungry, come for the spicy spring. It does not disappoint.