Prince Street Pizza

From the One Bite Fest, come for the pepperoni square. I far prefer round, but that's not what you get when you come here: go square. Nice sauce on top square, tangy sauce, excellent cup and char pepperoni, slice reheats well, got the whole pilowy yet crunch thing going on in the interior vs. exterior. Prince Street and Made In New York make a near identical Square. There's a whole controversy around that I forgot the details of but both make a great square. Yes, you can't eat it everyday unless you don't care and pig out everyday, because it's greasy. But you buy this slice to fucking enjoy it.

Prince Street pizza certainly didn't live up to its hype as one of the best pizzas in New York City. Sauce and cheese average at best. The pepperoni cups make this slice worth eating but nothing to brag about that makes it distinct in a city that prides itself as the Pizza Capital.

You get what you get, and you don’t get upset… unless you’re at one of the supposedly best pizza joints in the city. I’m going to assume that because they were RIDICULOUSLY busy, they were just rushing them out. Nothing to see here. There wasn’t anything good I can say. Wasn’t crispy, too much cheese, sauce wasn’t anything special, and I hate when the throw it in the box and a slice gets folded in half like that. We ordered a pie, which was supposed to take 10-15 minutes according to the guy, and it was more like 45 minutes. Wasn’t thrilled about that either… the one good slice of the bunch was that Sicilian with the pepperoni. Had some kick to it. The white was ok. Regular… was just that… regular.

Very crispy, lots of sauce which i LOVED, it was a great slice

Great flavor, but crust was undercooked and doughy. Crust looks better in other reviews so I’ll give it another shot.

Vibe is weird there but sauce is really good

Square slices are easily the best I’ve ever had in my life. Perfectly cooked and packs big flavor. A must try spot for anyone that likes squares! Regular NY slice probably an 8.0ish.

Always a long line, which has prevented me and my wife from checking it out, but it moves fast so we hopped on. Pretty much worth the hype. Incredibly solid, reminded me a lot of Joe’s.

Totally overrated. Nothing more than your typical average NYC slice.

The upside down was to die for and the pepperoni was excellent as well.

A classic favorite deserves a visit and rescore every time. This one did not disappoint. Previous squares resulted in some overdone bites that were too charred and dry. This was the perfect amount of crisp and fluffy crust. Spicy pepps were on point as always. Had me regretting only ordering 1 slice.

Spicy spring is top tier

Was an 8.5 before I tried the pepperoni slice, personally pepperoni is not my thing but this was amazing

They wouldn’t put that much pepperoni on the pizza unless it was fantastic. All pro OLineman.

Good