Prison Street Pizza

Reheated so I “burned my face off”. Thin, crispy but decent flop. Could have used a touch more sauce, all in all not bad

Good prices for slices and beer on the island.

Great crisp almost no flop sauce is just a little tangy for me thin crispy crust

Crust was way too chewey. Burned my mouth too

Great slice. No flop, thin, great crisp, great flavor.

Good thin crust NY style

Burnt...good sauce...but over cooked...

Solid pizza. The crust was crispy and there was grease but i couldn’t get the original cheese i’m on vacation let me live a little. Give this place a try you won’t be sad.

Good solid slice. Cheese is Good no flop at all. Could’ve had more sauce to it. Solid slice none the less.

A solid pie, good toppings and sauce but the crust was so-so... best pie I’ve had in the area but that ain’t sayin much..

Wanted to like this pizza so badly. Had potential. NO FLAVOR. Cheese was a gritty texture. Sauce was lacking. Serious waste of calories

Soild slice. Great crisp, no flop. Cheese is decent, sauce doesn’t have much tang. But overall not too bad. Definitely worth a try.

Nope. Pretty good thin crust consistency, but no flip and no flavor. A bland and boring slice. Wanted to like it, but I just can’t get there.

Solid flop, definitely some grease but comes with the territory when getting pep. Rest of my family got a veggie but I’m not about that life

Pretty good slice. Not greasy at all.

Solid slice. Thin, crispy, nice flavor to the sauce. Closest to a NY slice that you will get on West Maui.

Lacks cheese good sauce and crunch

Solid pizza. Little bit of that Lahaina flop. Great sauce and crust

Guy from asbury park nj set up this nice shop. Great pizza, very chill vibe. The locals say this is the only spot.