Pudgie's Pizza, Pasta & Subs - Elmira

Best Pizza in all of Upstate New York

Soft and doughy all the way through. Flavorful red sauce with a discrete but certain sweetness. A whole sheet doesn’t stand a chance

Pudgies pizza. Where more is more. Gluttony on a slice of cloud like dough. Truly a staple to the southern tier area and a popular choice among those who have grown up with the “Pudgies Party Pack” for christmas dinners and birthday parties year after year after year after year. As far as the pizza goes, it’s very cheesy, very saucy and very doughy. Crust has a nice crisp and the flavor is uniquely okay and almost addictive strangely. Secret ingredient? ;) Thanks

This pizza is fantastic. The only reason I don’t rate it higher is because the dough is thicker than I like. But the sauce is fantastic. Best pizza in Elmira.

Good doughy pizza, the sheet pizza is better then the single slice

Greasy, sweet sauce, and loaded with cheese! Great crust! This is the pizza for game day or a massive hangover, either way, it’s good! I give it a 7.5, dipping it into blue cheese...7.3 straight cheese! Solid pizza!

This is my Fathers hometown and high-school fast food stop. Love the people, love ALL the food. It’s soft but the crust is crunchy, 100% flop and the toppings always stay on. I give it a STRONG 7.75

Good football pizza

Football pizza. Better in a sheet on Sundays. Very doughy like your body after skipping the gym for a couple months and you’ve just been eating here during that time. Greasy like a homeless mans hair. Dip in a wing sauce to make it better. Chicken Wing pizza is their best. Very Ok.