About Pudgie's Pizza
22 Yelp Reviews
d.dorazio8/20/21, 4:14 p.m.
I'm giving Pudgies a flat 5. Maybe one of the lowest scores that I've ever given. It probably deserves an even lower score but the girl working the counter was really nice. I think she thought I was broke because I only bought one slice and I payed with coins, lol, $3.01 for a slice? Wtf? . After she rang me up she asked me if I was sure that I only wanted 1 slice. She had a caring and concerned look on her face that was very sweet. But little did she know that I had just eaten 2 slices from their competition next door and was trying to squeeze 2 reviews in on one lunch break 😅. I actually took one bite of this slice and knew right away that I would not take another. Just look at the picture, it tastes like it looks.
weswes10/21/20, 5:43 p.m.
Oh the pizza of my youth. Crust is doughy with zero crunch. Sauce tastes like paste from a can. Not much Italian spice at all. Cheese is solid. Seems like straight up mozzarella. Used to love Pudgies back in the day, but have not been impressed since they came back to town. Too much sauce.
colin.tyrrell5/11/19, 5:31 p.m.
The buffalo chicken wing and honey bbq chicken pizza is next level, way better then the vestal bakery
davidchilson4/22/19, 6:16 p.m.
Average pizza. Doesn’t taste much different than a frozen pizza from wegmans. Would definitely recommend Pudgies sheet pizza instead.