collwilx8212/23/19, 12:28 a.m.
Sal didn’t have any more pies left for slices so he made me one, but by the time I got to eat this slice it was cold, full disclosure. Sal threw this bad boy in the oven and went into the lobby to play the saxophone for some kids who had just finished dinner. Sax 10/10. Pizza is thin and crispy, not oily at all and has very flavorful sauce. The ambiance is raw and old in this hideaway pizza shoppe. If you’re at the zoo or nearby, this is a mandatory stop!!!!!
evan.manafort10/9/19, 1:44 a.m.
Pugsley’s penne pizza is the best pizza I’ve ever had. And I’m from New Haven.
jack.townsend10/7/19, 9:54 p.m.
Puglseys is the best pizza in NYC. No flop, crispy crust, fresh cheese, large slices. Garlic knots are insane also.
emma.sammons10/7/19, 9:21 p.m.
There is literally nothing more important to me than Pugsleys. The garlic Parmesan mix in the Gatorade bottle changed my life and I refuse to eat pizza without it.
ving103110/6/19, 6:30 p.m.
Great NY slice - always fresh ingredients I like it better than Joes!