While I may be a smooth brained ape of a retard there is no denying that the grandma and grandpa slice from Raimo’s is delicious. I have driven over 20 miles to bring friends to have a slice from here. Ignore the clowns. Take my suggestion and give this place a try.
matt.sagona11/26/20, 4:15 a.m.
Raimo’s Sicilian is the best Sicilian pizza I’ve ever had in NY. Better yet the best I’ve ever had anywhere. Raimo’s should advertise their Sicilian exclusively because I truly feel it can’t be beat. The cheese is plentiful, the thick soft dough and the crunchy bottom coupled with the sauce that seems to taste better than their regular slice works well. The best way to eat their Sicilian is to buy a slice, or a pie, take it home and throw it in the over for about 8 mins. When you reheat it I find that it comes out the best because it adds a delicious crunch to It. Eating it fresh though is still great. The re-heat method is just a personal preference I have.
dominic.annese5/30/20, 3:05 a.m.
So bad i didnt even take a photo. Doughy, Undercooked, heavy football pie. Below average, not good at all. Worse than Sbarro
sgt.pizza3/9/20, 5:37 p.m.
Regular: dough is on the softer side, sauce to cheese ratio is off with the cheese being the bigger percentage. Sauce tastes good just need less cheese and more sauce 6.7 Grandma: dough is cooked pretty tomato tastes great but the garlic used is overpowering. 7.2 Sicilan: slightly to thick for a traditional sicilan. Decent crunch on the bottom and soft in the middle. Again sauce and cheese ratio is off. Not half bad 7.4
jay.marine2/8/20, 2:56 p.m.
Solid slice! Nice thin, liiiitle crispy.. could always be a little more crispy in my book. Sauce good, crust ok. Overall solid good football slice. 👍
jeremy.greenberg112/30/19, 2:39 a.m.
Pretty good neighborhood pizza if you like a thicker slice. Great sauce, very sweet. Best pizza in the syosset/Woodbury area.
8 views•2 likes
joe.casteleneto12/27/19, 8:15 p.m.
Sicilian review. Good crisp, while maintaining a soft but cooked through interior. Sauce is amazing, excellent tang. Nicely seasoned. Cheese is heavy and well distributed, with little grease. Cooked perfectly, and no reheat because the pie was fresh. This is definitely their specialty.
andrew.lembo12/26/19, 6:04 p.m.
Pizza is very doughy and oily. Sauce is sweet and cheese isn’t great. Football pizza
david.chandler9/18/19, 12:21 a.m.
After the new owners took over the Pizza isn’t the same, workers are not Friendly, do not say Thank You, no smile, Pizza has too much Sauce and very thick, heavy,
timpy637/23/19, 9:15 p.m.
Sauce had a nice tang to it. Nice amount of cheese without it being greasy. One of the few softer slices that u like.....That’s my review.
papagiorgio3/21/19, 12:42 a.m.
Terrible. Greasy with absolutely no taste. Usually you could save a mediocre slice by adding some grated cheese but no amount of Parmesan will make this stuff good
kevin.rozell1/18/19, 10:30 p.m.
Great pizza. My favorite cheese to sauce ratio. Cheesier than most. Best regular slices in the area. They also serve up great chicken parm, chicken rolls (don’t forget a cup of marinara on the side), meatball heroes, gelato, etc.
matt.palczewski1/14/19, 5:48 p.m.
a little flop on the regular slice. Silician slice was solid I’d give that an 8. PS Fight me Portnoy you pussy
chris.antonacci112/28/18, 6:19 p.m.
Super cheesy super oily good crunch not the best around but a decent slice