Ralph's Pizzeria

Good solid slice. Great crisp and flavor, wouldn’t put it up in the 9s but it’s fire.

Sauce hits the spot. This place is the place for delicious thin crust locally!

Pizza was really good, one of my favorite by far.

Very solid pizza, just not really my style. Sort of reminds me of a Home Run Inn frozen pizza but way way better. Still though, see why people love this, just not really my style. Above average with great crisp.

Thin and crispy for the win. One of the best pizzas I’ve had. If I wasn’t in the area I’d come running for this pizza.

Excellent pizza. Thin crust that’s not too doughy (I hate thick, doughy pie). The cheese is exquisite. However, The pizza is a bit over done, and I really like well done pizza but it’s a little too much. As good as it was, I think Amore Pizza in Nutley may be better

Best slice around

Max’s first review for his uncle Ben: Ralph’s in Nutley, NJ.

One of the best pies I ever had , thin crust, great flavor , if you lover of a great bar pie or any type of pie, you have to drive up asap!!

Margarita slice was one of the best I’ve ever had. Always chasing the Ralph dragon since I took my first ever bite. My friend Matt also agrees as well.

Thin, crispy and delicious.

Really good but a little too much tomato sauce for me. The cheese would come right when biting.

Solid. pretty greasy.

Very good

Not as good as I was hoping for but a very good quality pie. Good crust. This was ordered with extra sauce.

I loved the sauce, amount of cheese, and the crisp. The crust is light and airy but it is doughy such that there is a slight chew required with each bite. A solid thin-crust pie overall.

Quintessential Bar pie, very tasty. Add a full point if it’s your thing like it is for Dave

Had to go after seeing Pres’s review. It checks out on all fronts: high quality cheese and sauce, and crispy crust. Not quite as thin as I expected. All around great pie. Pricey at $21 for 1 half topping but worth it. Doesn’t quite live up to Pres’s hype but still a great pie.

25 min drive for a Portnoy 8.9. Good not great, however, I devoured half a pie in my car outside Ralph’s in under 5 min. Sauce good, right amount of cheese grease, crispy undercarriage and crust. Not a big fan of thin pies, which this is. Thin is in with women, but not for pies as far as I’m concerned.

Very good. Crispy. Great cheese. Thin. Very good

Super thin, nice and well done, amazing crisp, and great sauce. Crazy thing about the crust, it almost tastes like Sicilian but in a super thin form

Liked the pizza, LOVED the place. You don’t get more North Jersey than Ralph’s in Nutley. Tiny takeout Italian place, with an old school guy flinging pies behind the counter. The crisp and crust was 9.0+ level, exactly how you want your pie to feel and look. But the cheese and sauce were a little bland and had me wanting more oomph. Overall good. Worth the visit, but no way is it near an all-time great as Portnoy says.

Good sauce, crispy slice, but definitely on the small side.