alex.kim61/6/21, 11:06 p.m.
VERY GOOD! Sauce is on the sweeter side which i loved. The Marinara pizza is also very good. It had pieces of garlic on it which make it even better!
joseph.vanacore.iii12/31/20, 12:45 a.m.
Dave, I don't know how this was a 8.9. The sauce is excellent. One of the best sauces I've had on pizza. Cheese was great too. The pizza looked well done but the bottom didn't have that pizza crunch, it was soft and felt like I was eating an elios pizza. I don't know what it was, the dough or how it was cooked but I was not a fan of that. Definitely great sauce and cheese but didn't have that crunch. Good pizza. 7.8 that's a review.
joe.namendorf12/21/20, 6:44 p.m.
good crisp, similar to bar pie but thicker. lots of flavor. good sauce, floppy
joey.crinion12/21/20, 12:09 a.m.
Probably one of the best i ever had. No words its a must try.
matthew.divozzo12/15/20, 12:20 a.m.
Went here specifically because Dave loved it so much. 8.9 is a HUGE score. Went out of my way to go here. Ordered a pizza at 5:19pm. Was told it will be ready in 25 mins. Got there at 5:50 and didn’t leave until 6:35. System is awful. Not sure if covid is to blame or anything and I don’t want to be too harsh. My pizza was very cold when I got it so I feel I did not get the full experience. All the people waiting outside with me were also very frustrated and said that it wasn’t the first time it happened. Hey, I’ll wait an hour for a pizza, that’s fine. But just let me know it’s gonna be an hour... maybe I’ll try around lunch time instead.
hvpizzaking12/10/20, 9:16 p.m.
Another Portnoy blunder. The sauce was pretty good, crust was OK, and the cheese was lackluster. I preferred the thin over the regular but the dough recipe reminded me of a frozen pizza. Dave put this in the same league as Johnny's in Mount Vernon and they aren't even in the same stratosphere. Nice people but this might be his worst review to date.
pizzavore12/7/20, 11:35 p.m.
2 cheese slices and a bottle of water, 3:20pm on a Monday, $7.18 Pros: Cooked well, nice well done flavor in the crust and cheese, the sauce is fantastic and there's a good amount of it. Very tangy and flavorful, I'd say it was the most memorable part. Cons: Slices are a bit small but the thickness gives them some substance Verdict: The sign out front boasts 75 years of business and this place holds an 8+ rating after hundreds of reviews, so the bar was set high for Ralph's. Very good, almost great couple of slices today. I came in during the 3 hour on a Monday, which would mean terrible, unfresh pizza almost anywhere. This was still good enough to be in the 8's during a terrible business hour, so I could see this possibly being even better at a busier time of day.
shafirs12/5/20, 1:47 a.m.
Kinda disappointed thought it would be better. Good for sure but not the best
adam.messier11/24/20, 7:30 p.m.
A little doughy for a thin crust, still good flavor, not bad of a crisp
johnny.warhawks11/20/20, 1:50 a.m.
Great pizza! The sauce is different, but the flavor is 100%
zekeeatspizza11/16/20, 8:15 p.m.
Little NJ flop for Zeke but he is wowed again. This might be (probably is) the best crust I’ve ever had. Perfectly crisped, a little burn on the top and it goes phenomenal with the rest of the pizza. The crunch, the sweet sweet sauce, and great cheese. You can really tell they use fresh ingredients. Zeke is in loved with this place, Nutley has a gem. Zeke approves with flying colors.
ed.drilon11/15/20, 2:49 p.m.
Now I see what all the hype was about, tops so far of all pizzas in nj