Ralph's Pizzeria

I was so excited to try it, but left disappointed. The sauce is great. But the crust was too hard and cheese wasn’t …cheesy.

Cheese was amazing, I was expecting it to taste burnt and dry considering the looks of the pizza, but it tasted really creamy and was the best part of the pizza. Very thin and crispy crust, I didn't taste the sauce that much.

Phenomenal slice. Crushed an entire pie by myself it was so good. 110% lives up to Dave’s score plus more IMO

8.9!? Good pizza I like it! not an 8.9 though

Outstanding cheese. Sauce. Crust.

Great crust. Cooked perfectly

Wanted to like it more, solid pizza. Granted I like a sweeter crust. The thin by itself is a 7.9

Amazing pizza. Simple as that

Excellent pizza! Light, crispy, flavorful. No oil. Smashed the whole pie in 15 min!

The cheese was super fresh and good, you definitely gotta eat this warm or hot because it activates the flavor in the sauce. The crust is also really good. Great pie, no flop.

I have eaten pizza from all over the US and this is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had and the service is impeccable!

Loved this thin crust beauty.

Very very good

Ended up here by accident before going to a football game, had no clue that it was rated a 8.9 by Davey, it lived up to the hype. Had 4 slices, the second two better than the first two as once it cooled down and my mouth wasn’t melted I was able to enjoy one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time. Great crisp, sauce was ok the sweet side , though there was tons of oil, it didn’t take away from the structure of the slice. My nuts were on the floor in Nutley!

Great pizza super convenient and not too expensive, staff was awesome

Rating is on the regular thin slice. Very crispy and great flavor. I would give the margherita pizza a 7.9