Excellent pizza. Thin crust that’s not too doughy (I hate thick, doughy pie). The cheese is exquisite. However, The pizza is a bit over done, and I really like well done pizza but it’s a little too much. As good as it was, I think Amore Pizza in Nutley may be better
sarah.ashworth12/20/24, 7:03 p.m.
Small seating area, but GREAT pizza and friendly staff. We will be back anytime we are in the area!
smcguire332/18/24, 2:00 a.m.
Thinner crust but not quite bar pie. More chewy than crispy with little flavor. Cheese dominates for me, which I tend not to love. Nothing putting it over the top imo but can see it being a solid enough go-to if you live nearby
giantpants12/29/23, 1:33 a.m.
Really tough to score. This pizza is great. Super light crust and a cooked perfectly. Nice sauce and subtle cheese with lots of bubbles. One of my favorite pizzas that I will definitely return for.
kyle.varanyak12/26/23, 9:42 p.m.
#2 on the north jersey trip. Way cheesier than Angeloni’s but super similar crust. Going a little lower cause a bit too cheesy.
pizzacato12/23/23, 3:22 a.m.
Wow. Intensely flavorful and incredibly crispy. Amazing. I wish I lived near here. Definitely coming back and bringing my wife next time. That sauce just lights up your mouth.
harris.baker12/18/23, 12:06 a.m.
Back in Jersey and wanted to try this spot for my birthday as it’s Dave’s highest rated in my area that I haven’t been to. From the looks of it online I didn’t expect it to live up to the 8.9 rating, but had to see for myself. It was crispy and had no flop, but crust may have been a bit too crispy. Cheese was great but wish sauce had more flavor. Still pretty good overall
will.ketelsen12/13/23, 6:40 p.m.
This pizza is pretty good. It's a little well done which I'm not the biggest fan of but it doesn't make it worse in any way. It has a pretty thick crust so thake that as you will. The cheese was alright, and I think they could use a bit more sauce but overall not bad.
ezrac12/9/23, 11:16 p.m.
Amazing pizza. The char was amazing on the crust. The cheese has an interesting uniqueness to it. Only thing i had a problem with was how oily it was.
pizza.bandits12/5/23, 3:33 p.m.
Bandits disputed on this one. Bandit one found there to be a lack of sauce and a weird aftertaste. Bandit 2 however did not find any issues with sauce proportion and liked the uniqueness of the cheese. However both could agree that the crisp was crispy. Eggcellent crisp. Bandit 1- 7.6 Bandit 2- 8.4 Bandit 1- Ralph’s, how ya doing Ralph’s. Bandit 2- Ralph’s how ya doing Ralph’s. Ralph’s you can come on over.
joey.cusamano11/26/23, 12:20 a.m.
Got it well done but some slices were like a piece of charcoal! Take out of the oven and Bring it ova. lotta hype about this place. The PorkBoy went too high as usual, he likes the bougie spots doesn’t he? I give it this, it’s a clean pie. I’m gonna go 7.9. If it was my local spot, I’d like it, but I would long for the days of an old school slice.
brendan.harer11/25/23, 11:42 a.m.
Excellent Pizza - Best I’ve had since Sally’s in New Haven and Mr.01 in Miami
carter.domis11/18/23, 9:47 p.m.
was sitting in the box for a while but this was a great slice.
jake.thoden10/25/23, 10:46 p.m.
I’ll give ‘em the benefit of the doubt since I liked it a lot even though I went with a slice that may have been sitting there for a while. Just don’t order their buffalo pie because TOMATO SAUCE DOES NOT BELONG ON BUFFALO PIZZA
mickla2710/19/23, 12:03 a.m.
A little bit floppy and greasy but over all good pie. Reminds me of a crisper Contes
ryan.colella10/6/23, 9:55 p.m.
Zero flop, crispy. Really light. Feel like it could have used more sauce. Never have felt this, but thr oil from the pepperoni softened the bite just enough.
m.herman9989/22/23, 6:11 p.m.
I don’t get the hype. It tasted like I was eating lasagna, not pizza