Randy's Wooster St Pizza Naples

As of 8/22/26, this is easily the best pizza in Maine on the Portnoy scale. The crust was crisp, but doesn’t cut the inside of your mouth. The sauce also had amazing fresh tomato flavor. I do have some criticism to justify the 8.4 which is in regard to the cheese. This was a 2 napkin pie. The cheese also left much to be desired in the flavor department. Those are my thoughts. This place completely deserves to be in the 8s.

I got the Hot Wheel Pizza - amazing pizza 👍great flavor, the perfect combination of flavor and heat!

Classic New Haven style pie. Pro Tip: order it well done to get that gorgeous char on the crust and undercarriage. Tomato sauce could use a little zip, very mild. They go pretty light on the cheese which is just the way I like it.

The. Real. Deal.

A quality pie. I highly recommend getting the well done it give a zero flop experience. The cheese is on par and pairs nicely with the sauce. The real winner here is the undercarriage, absolutely magnificent.

Great thinner crust, nice and crispy, a winner.

Thin & crispy. Charred up nicely.

Holy friggin pissah what a treat in the middle of I did not see that coming. Well done indeed

Overall great pizza. Fantastic cheese and sauce. Crust was good too!

Crust was great. No flop. Sauce was good. Asked for it between normal and well and I could have handled a little more well. Best pizza I’ve had outside of CT.

By far the best pizza I have had in Maine.

One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had in my life went 2 times on my vac got try popcorn pizza

God awful we also got chicken and it was red and raw!

Great crust and flavor. Ingredients are robust. Place has 48 different pizzas. Had pepperoni and mushroom.

This shit is 🔥🔥

Won't find a better pizza north of CT! Reminds me of home!

Straight up good pizza. Crust was excellent. Everything else was good. If anything sauce was a little wet and plain. But no complaints overall. Crust was the best part for sure

Best in the Northeast for sure!!