Grabbed a few slices, they were cooked well done, the sauce is fantastic, cheese was high quality with not a lot of grease and the crust was crisp. I do understand the Rolls-Royce of Dominos analogy but I like Dominos and I loved this pizza.
pat.perry4/14/22, 7:00 p.m.
Greasy. Doughy. Bad under carriage. Fresh out the oven disappointing slice.
wadezzeria3/28/22, 2:32 a.m.
2nd review, almost 3 years later… C.O.B (cheese on bottom) proper sauce:cheese:crust ratio is a must to balance out the crazy sweet sauce
lloyd.jr9/25/21, 9:20 p.m.
The sauce, cheese and crust were all very good but the end of the slice was a bit floppy and doughy. Overall very good slice.
dan.ciccone8/27/21, 6:52 p.m.
Good but not great pretty standard basic football pizza, Prez was right front counter girl ridiculous guess that boosted his score up a few points
newjerseydevil7/20/21, 5:50 p.m.
Sweet sauce. Needed to be done a little more on the regular slice.
john.sherry6/30/21, 11:49 p.m.
What a joke went there because of Dave’s reviews, got there at 7:25 place was locked up sign said closes at 8 really!!!
emily.krazzelberry6/29/21, 5:47 p.m.
Score is for both slices combined-COB was really good, nice sweet sauce. Regular slice wasn’t bad, good cheese but lots of flop. Overall good slices 🍕
pizza_nick6/29/21, 5:46 p.m.
This rating is for the COB. The COB(cheese on bottom) slice was good. Definitely a different texture. Sauce was sweet, cheese was good, dough was thick and soft. 7.2 for the COB. Unofficial review of the regular slice. Regular slice was okay. I'd give that a 6.4. Reminds me of Stewart's pizza for all of you fellow upstate New Yorkers.
frado933/18/21, 1:42 a.m.
Boneless Pizza cheese is a 6.2 I like pepperoni pizza so my rate is for the pepperoni half. sauce is so iffy ?hard.water?Noidea crust was the only crispy part (*7.2*bacon steak n cheese (a1 on the side but should be cooked with the a1 hopefully next time)
zachary.worthington5/19/20, 10:53 p.m.
Gotta get the C.O.B. Pizza here at Red Front (Cheese On Bottom). You can tell all the ingredients are Quality. Crispy crust(iasked for it to be well done), sweet sauce with great flavor and no acidity, and the cheese was great, it made for some good cheese pulls but not because it was loaded with cheese, i just think the type of mozz they use does that. I love this pizza. It could use a little less sugar in the sauce but its still great. Especially for the area. Ya gotta try it.
rachel.baumgartner3/29/20, 7:43 p.m.
wish it was a tiny bit crisper but overall delicious! great sauce nice and cheesy
beastnipples12/27/19, 12:43 a.m.
Saucy and doughy sums this pie up. Sauce is sweet. The crust has a soft crispness to it. Good amount of cheese. A little greasy. Not a lot of crispness on the bottom. Basically a pan style pizza. If you like a thicker/doughy pizza then this will appeal to you.
chris.pistorio8/28/19, 12:19 a.m.
Sauce is too sweet. Crust is doughy in the middle of the pizza. Could be a few more pepperoni on the pizza. Average pizza
kholzrpi8/25/19, 10:56 p.m.
Listen, this place has a great slice. The sauce and crust are unique, but the cheese was god awful. It slid right off anyways. You know that gummy type cheese? It was almost like rubber. I think the guy put too much on, but I gotta rate it how it was to me. Otherwise, the slice looks amazing, staff was super nice, and the atomosphere is very welcoming. Ill be back to try them again, just the cheese was pretty bad.
nick.holzhauer8/25/19, 10:34 p.m.
Sauce is out of this world. Crust is GOOD. Cheese is little rubbery and doesn’t stick to the crust.
mookie338/18/19, 12:32 a.m.
The pizza looks really great but the taste is just ok. Sauce is very sweet and lacks depth. If you like it sweet, mid 7s is definitely possible. The crust was pretty good but overall I expected it to be better.