Red Wagon Pizza Company

Looks the part first off. The daughter loved the crust for whatever that’s worth. Wife didn’t. Thin with no flop. Wife gave it a 6.8, I’ll bump it to a 6.9

Had several different kinds and quite decent.

Final pizza stop on my Minneapolis 2026 New Years Pizza run. $16 for the 10 inch pepperoni. Crust was a bit floppy and chewy but cornmeal was kind of unique. Really kind of meh with sauce and pepperoni. Cheese was good. Compared to my last stop yesterday this was much better. But not as close to the top tier places in the twin cities.

Man, was hoping for more on this one, but came up short. Lots of flop even though it was paper thin and wasn’t very impressed with the tastes of the pepperoni, crust, or cheese. Just not my style of pie. However, top notch staff and atmosphere!

Great pizza. The Red Wagon is fantastic. Margarita is great too!

Cinderella

Enjoyed how thin it was, but pretty floppy. Nice amount of sauce and cheese but felt like the sauce didn’t have much flavor and I wanted to salt it! Not a fan of cornmeal on the crust but that’s a personal preference.

Good thin crust. Tasty.

Ordered well done, little bit of flop, good undercarriage, good cheese, good sauce, good solid pizza. Would recommend if you’re in the area.

Took it take out but it wasn’t cooled off when I ate it. They charged a 4$ service fee on an 15$ pizza which was wild to me. Pizza was fine but it didn’t blow my socks off like it did it’s first couple years here. Prime red wagon would get an 8. But this plane, 4$ service fee pizza is barely worthy of a 7.1

Quite heavy on the garlic, kept it from being a bit higher but if that’s your thing, it’s really good pizza.

Went with the Red Wagon pizza. It has heat to it. Overall great flavor good crust. Not a traditional judging pizza but it was a solid 8.2

Really solid pie all around. A little floppy but it’s everything I really enjoy in a cheese slice!

Great pizza

Loved how fresh this pizza tasted and an all around great vibe.

Pepperoni pizza.

Extremely good pizza. The flop was a little much, but it didn’t really take away from the overall taste. Would totally come back all the way from Kansas City!

Unique ingredients with great flavors! Crust is thin and straight forward, a good all around pie

Strong flavors and sauce. The body could be tighter IMO