Alrighhtttttt. Let’s get one thing straight, I’m from NJ, and we feel a little slighted on some of his terrible reviews. So, I’m up in his home turf and gonna give some reviews myself. Each bite was different. Lots of flour on the pizza I thought (underneath and on the crust) , the sauce was bland with certain bites and then tasted not bad at all. I like it well done and the crust itself had no snap to it when biting, the top part of the crust was good. The cheese/sauce combination had moments. All in all not my favorite but terrible. Be on the lookout for the next review rebuttable!!!
coop794/17/21, 1:12 a.m.
Great Pizza, drove all the way from Chester PA to try it on a mini pizza vacation. Diffinatly is a must try pizza. But you have to eat it fresh out of the oven when it’s still hot and the cheese is melted. I found the crust to get a bit hard when it cooled. But it was outstanding flavor, fresh, the crust was just perfect with a great crisp. And it wasn’t loaded with oil. I will be back for another pie
max.rumble3/28/21, 6:58 p.m.
The crust was a good mix of crispy and floppy. Sauce was flavorful and cheese was great. Great pie.
adammjensen3/19/21, 12:41 a.m.
Ridiculously doughy. What I’d call bowling alley pizza. Portnoy had to be ripped off his face to put this in the 9’s
patrickmoskal3/16/21, 1:50 a.m.
people who own the place are amazing people but the pizza just isn’t. this pie needs some new york water
slicknick353/14/21, 5:05 p.m.
Came here because Dave compared my favorite Nj pizzeria to them. Little crisp. Barely any sauce or taste of sauce. It was only a little warm. Good undercarriage. Cheese was decent. Taste a little bit like perfect pizza in jersey but I like perfect better. The old woman at the counter was rude.
billypetrangelo2/28/21, 5:42 p.m.
Never got the chance to snap a picture of this beautiful pizza. Went here in September for 1 slice before going out for Italian food. Should have just went here. Best pizza I’ve had so far. Crust is fucking amazing. Closest to a 9 I’ve had
manny.gomes2/27/21, 5:21 p.m.
Dave was not being bias. This is a solid pizza. Crunch, crispy, good cheese, tasty sauce, cheese didn't fall off, the crust tasted great, and no flop. What more could you want? 9.1 all day.
djcott332/14/21, 11:46 p.m.
Don’t get me wrong... it was GOOD... did it the same day as Santarpio’s... was a close contest...
hawkeye7661/6/21, 4:04 a.m.
Easily my favorite pizza If you like a softer crust ask for it lightly cooked it was absolutely perfect.
papidunno12/24/20, 9:57 p.m.
Didn’t have time to get a whole pie which probably affected the outcome of the pizza, anyways, Dave definitely gave this a hometown rating. The sauce was underwhelming, but the crust was amazing, fantastic crunch in every bite. Overrated? Slightly. Still an elite pie? Yup.
hill valley.brewing11/25/20, 3:44 a.m.
Ordered well done, not sure if that was a mistake or not. Definitely better than Santarpios.
haley.ferreira111/22/20, 7:30 p.m.
This pizza tastes no different than the other locations. Good pizza but not even close to being the best. Sbarro is better lol