Besides our god awful delivery time (2 hours) on a Monday night and the poor excuses for why it was late (live less than a mile away), the pizza was ok. Nothing wrong with the pizza here. This leans more toward a late night spot for a very cheesey and greasy slice. I ordered a thin crust pepperoni pizza. We were hungry, and Renaldi's did hit the spot. The cheese is very chewy and stringy. I wish it has a little more seasoning as it was slightly bland, but the salt from the pepperoni seemed to help out with that. The non-sweet sauce was limited and could've added more to the flavor. I had a few good bites where everything tasted perfect together, but it was pretty inconsistent. The crust was cooked well, not crispy, but cooked. I wouldn't call this NY style even though it's cut in triangles, because it wasn't crazy thin. I'll order again if I have one of their coupons handy.
chance.richards1/10/21, 9:01 p.m.
This is the Spingione with sausage and capicollo. Awesome style of pizza, tasty crust, not too heavy on cheese so add some extra if that’s youre thing. Great pie
jakegordon9/20/20, 4:57 p.m.
This is a major league slice of pizza. Not sure what everyone else is reviewing on here. Crust is perfect, really good cheese to sauce ratio. Only con is there was a fair amount of grease. Catch me eating this 7 days a week and twice on sundays, Bear down
j.stev4/19/20, 9:07 p.m.
Nice thin slice. Crust sauce and cheese all compliment each other well. Great quick bite for $4
k.b.5/24/19, 1:49 a.m.
Bought 2 cheese slices, greasy af. Super floppy. Almost non-existent cheese. Also they advertise selling by the slice but also its a $10 minimum on cards? No thanks. Garbage
josh.wonsowski3/3/19, 8:38 a.m.
Cheese, sauce & crust are great. Score doesn't include the phenomenal atmosphere the place had. Go there any chance you can!
frank.garofalo11/19/18, 3:44 a.m.
Greasy and kind of sour tasting. Not a great pizza by any means.
ohdangletsbang10/22/18, 1:49 a.m.
The Sicilian style is much better than the normal pizza. Also their garlic bread is next level.
perplexedsloth10/3/18, 12:23 a.m.
Best attribute is the crust which, for a thin crust, has a nice balance between crisp and chew. The cheese is definitely on the greecy end. The pizza here is also on the pricey end, $4+ slices. Would consider this place better to go in person for the ambiance rather than a takeout pizza.
hans.paap9/29/18, 10:33 p.m.
Grease everywhere over priced. tastes like a convenient store slice of pizza that I just paid three extra dollars for.
41 views•3 likes
pizzafunk9/24/18, 1:18 a.m.
Cheese explosion. Excellent pepperoni. Light sauce. Could use more flavor on crust. Still, best thin crust in Chicago.
petesayparty9/11/18, 12:28 a.m.
A rich blend of homemade sauce and cheese topped on a delicious crust. Overall worth a try!