Renato's Pizza Masters

In hindsight, if I let the slice cool down a bit and settle I think it could have been low 7’s. But as it was I felt fine giving a 6.8. Nice crisp crust and liked that there was no flop, but an average flavor.

Quite generic pizza solid though I’m right with the community score

Vodka pie was very good, medium dough and could have been cooked a minute or two longer, and a lot of cheese

Excellent pizza! I recommend the eggplant and fresh garlic as toppings! Service was excellent. A touch more salt and this would have been an 8.1

Lots of cheese, good crisp, sauce is ok.

Floppy af. Great sauce, very greasy.

OK pizza review time. Still in Jersey City. This time at Renato‘s Pizza Masters. This place is been around for a long time so they must be doing something right. I have to say I was pretty darn impressed with the slice. Not my usual go to style because it is a little bit thicker than I usually like but thinner doesn’t always mean better. The dough had a good flavor with no flop and the taste didn’t feel doughy to me. Definitely a good balance of sauce N cheese. Both of which had good flavor and quality. One slice is definitely filling enough. I’ll be back again. 8.4 that’s the review. Same as I gave Rizzo but two totally different slices and experiences

Very tasty, enjoy the crust and the cheese to sauce ratio, Little floppy with a little too much grease but overall a good slice

Deec.

I came in last night because of Dave's review. I don't know why he gave it such a good score. I was disappointed. Too thick and all flop. I did like the taste but it was just an average pie. I won't go back.

Great spot for a slice in jersey city, slice was on the thicker and doughy side. Good pizza, really liked the round deep dish personal which had great sauce and flavor.

Good cheese, big flop, thicc slice

Floppy and not crispy but it was cheesy and had a good amount of sauce

Good for a microwave pizza, average for any other category

I don’t know what Dave was thinking with this one. If this is his 8.1, I don’t think I can trust his opinion anymore 😅

Pres over sold this, extremely doughy way to much cheese and oil. Would not go back.

Very greasy, little flop, Good cheese flavor, sauce is on the sweeter side, good crust. Good everyday pizza solid 7.7