Renato's Pizza Masters

Deec.

I came in last night because of Dave's review. I don't know why he gave it such a good score. I was disappointed. Too thick and all flop. I did like the taste but it was just an average pie. I won't go back.

Great spot for a slice in jersey city, slice was on the thicker and doughy side. Good pizza, really liked the round deep dish personal which had great sauce and flavor.

Good cheese, big flop, thicc slice

Floppy and not crispy but it was cheesy and had a good amount of sauce

Good for a microwave pizza, average for any other category

I don’t know what Dave was thinking with this one. If this is his 8.1, I don’t think I can trust his opinion anymore 😅

Pres over sold this, extremely doughy way to much cheese and oil. Would not go back.

Very greasy, little flop, Good cheese flavor, sauce is on the sweeter side, good crust. Good everyday pizza solid 7.7

Doughy and cheesy. Jersey slice here

7.6 Solid pizza , a bit oily and nothing stands out about it but it’s yummy

Pizza Masters truly deserves to be in the upper echelon of pizza slices. They must have renovated the inside since the last time I was here 8 years ago. But the sauce maintained that great rustic taste it has had since my youth. Once the slice cooled down, i could really enjoy the oozing cheese and fluffy dough. Stay strong, Renato’s.

Pizza here is always reheated never fresh unless you're buying a pie and it tastes like reheated at home, hot on the bottom and lacking on top

Solid, can set your watch to it. Decent amount of sauce, nice crunch. Borderline worth traveling for

Perfect crust to along with tasty mozz and a nice rustic plum tomato sauce. Very easy to polish one of these off single-handedly.

Margarita slice. Loaded with flavor, very sizable slices, crust is always just the right amount of crisp and everything always holds up. Best pizza in Jersey City, it’s not even close

Best in jersey city