Renna's Pizza

Always good pizza.

Still waiting for one fucking slice of cheese. Kitchen is fully staffed and the place is half empty. Been close to half hour now

i cheated and asked for it well done, regardless this shit is fucking gas and you're trippin' if you say otherwise. a solid 8.6

One of the better pies I've had in Jax. Perfect amount of grease, flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. Wish the crust was crisper, but overall a solid pizza.

Great taste. Cheese on point not crazy swimming in oil. Slices versus whole pie you can tell the difference.

I’m from NY... I wasn’t expecting NY pizza. Ordered a small (10”) veggie pizza. Felt like I was eating a taco in the rain. I actually threw it in the trash. Canned vegetables cheap mozzarella... frozen pizza from Publix is twice as good. One of the worst pizza experiences I have had.

Floppy. Greasy. Tastes like a better version of school pizza.

Not bad, not great. Greasy and could be more crispy

Loved this place when I was a kid. Solid slice, minimal flop, pretty greasy though. +.3 for nostalgia

Probably one of if not the best slice you will get in Orange Park. Consistent sauce, fluffy crust, a little too much flop. 7.2 Frankie.