Renna's Pizza West

Not a terrible pie, but not great. Very middle of the road. Solid enough crisp on the crust. The sauce tasted watered down and it was pretty greasy. It was on the thinner side which was a plus.

Sign in here says 31 year anniversary, you’d think after 31 years theyd have a little better recipe figured out. While its definitely not bad pizza, its not great either. Cheese and sauce are fine and its cooked in a real on... the dough is stretched by hand, it just falls short. Kind of like a cardboard feel to the dough and a bit much semolina on the bottom.

Place is nice, absolute murder trying to get in and out of the parking lot. Pizza has no flop, excellent crust not greasy. The more you eat this pizza the better it gets. Not the best, not the worst. Overall solid slice.

Not the best around, but If cooked fresh it can be some really good pizza

Best slice in olean