Renzo's Pizzeria & Restaurant

This slice had a nice pop of flavor in the sauce and didn’t overpower the overall flavor. It was thin and had some crispness. Really solid slice that I would think is the go to in the area.

Not good. Undercooked, 100% flop, too much cheese, flavorless.

The perfect slice . The homemade sauce really compliments the crispy crust and cheese . 10/10 would recommend to come down and get a slice for yourself , far better than anything else in the mount Sinai area.

Pepperoni with Hot Honey and half Burrata. Absolutely amazing.

Crispy, cheesy, saucy just the way pizza should be

The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside, and had just the right amount of char to give it a smoky flavor that elevated the pizza experience. The sauce to cheese ratio was spot on, with the tangy tomato sauce providing a perfect complement to the gooey and melty mozzarella cheese. I would highly recommend this pizza place to anyone looking for a top-notch pizza experience.

what more can i say? back to the old workers this pizza is one of the best around. perfectly cooked by friendly staff makes the best spot to get my weekly friday night pies. good flop. i’m going with aaaaaaaa……9.2 frankie highly recommend

This right here is how I expect my buffalo chicken slices to taste! Great crisp-to-chew ratio for the dough to hold up to the weight of the chicken. Chicken pretty juicy, does not have they overly fried taste. Well seasoned. Cheese on point with taste and pull.

Better then average football slice right here. On the thinner side with a slight crunch. Been coming here on and off for years. I’ve been told new owner, but the guy in there looked so familiar… 🤔 anyhoo, I can eat this on the regular for sure.

Greasy

Very good slice just was missing enough of my favorite part, the sauce. Crust and dough were very, very good, cheese had a nice fresh flavor, and sauce had a nice taste to it. The presentation was so good I forgot to take a picture before I engorged on it. If this slice had more sauce it’s in the 8’s for me I would assume.

Very good football pizza. That crust is nice and the sauce has a nice tang to it. If your having a party or watching the game this is a good spot.

Very good quality slice.

Been eating this pizza for 35 years. Consistently one of the best slices in Suffolk County.

Not bad at all. Nice crust. Taste the basil in the sauce. Solid slice

Good flavor, a little bit greasy on the sauce, ok crunch, has that flop. Overall not bad but needs work