Absolutely terrible. Portnoy losses major credibility giving this a 7.4. The cheese had a very strange flavor and I later learned they use a cheese mix which includes American Cheese??? Using American cheese on any pizza is sacrilegious. In all honesty Ellios frozen pizza is way better. Sorry to be so harsh but it was that bad.
robby.wander6/18/21, 8:22 p.m.
With Cafe Rinaldi and Cusumano closed until 5pm, I’m forced to go straight to Revello’s. Old Forge style is distinctive - and tasty. This one is thicker, cheesier, and fluffier than Arcaro, but it’s slightly greasier. Splitting hairs. Again, 8 worthy for a traveling Floridian.
brian.leckie16/14/21, 5:46 p.m.
Not bad pizza, just not worth the hype that Old Forge gets. Red is 6.6. White much better, like a 7.8 but can only eat a cut or two cause it’s super filling with the cheese.
ian.weeks5/6/21, 10:15 p.m.
The pizza was good but didn’t knock my socks off. Decent crisp but was Lacking some flavor, also super messy
richie.speruggia11/11/20, 6:26 p.m.
Wildly undercooked. And I just don’t like the Provel cheese they use.
george.edwards311/3/20, 12:04 a.m.
Crust is super crispy! Sauce is a little sweet. This is a staple of Old Forge!
tom.conway39/19/20, 10:08 p.m.
My favorite of the Old Forge spots. I just really enjoy the entire slice. Cheese, sauce, and crunch.
jim.cardona9/15/20, 10:19 p.m.
Taste of home... got a par bake from the supermarket to get my fix but I know this pizza well, light fluffy great sauce and cheese, can eat a whole tray (yes, tray) no problem, not far behind sabs
tim.kindt8/29/20, 9:32 p.m.
Not terrible, but not great either. Sauce was a little salty. Cheese was either all American or had Americans can blended in. I like all mozzarella.
enrico.connors8/2/20, 8:04 p.m.
Forgot to take a photo so here’s one from the internet. Love the cheesiness. The sauce is fresh and it’s not as crispy.
mcd51107/26/20, 6:24 p.m.
1st Old Forge experience. Pizza was crisp at the bottom but still fluffy inside. Did not disappoint