Reye's Pizza

Review based on the reheated slice. This is my go-to spot to satisfy that want-a-quick-slice-right-now need. Thin and crispy, with a somewhat sweet sauce, this slice hits the feels every time. Also, for 2.50 a slice, this is a great deal. Ran by a bunch of good dudes as well. Bring cash.

Can’t complain. Always solid and the best football pizza- prices here are the best plus the best cheese steak around for jersey

Tastes alright, but the grease flows like a river off the floppy end of this slice.

This Sicilian is incredible

Ok pizza

sweet sauce. good flop.

Shallow and pedantic

Love this place. Great sandwiches and wings as well.

It’s just ok jersey shore pizza not great not bad. I wouldn’t drive more than 10 minutes to get it

It all comes down to ingredients...sauce is ok, kind of sweet. The cheese could be better. Says it’s a New York slice...not really.

Very light, no crunch, Limited flop. Your average solid slice

This is great pizza. There is a large difference between the slices and the pies. Go the individual slice route. Best pizza I’ve had around my area.

Good pizza for grabbing once you’ve been out drinking. Got a couple extra points for the box. USA....USA....