Riella's Homestyle

Regular: dough is really crispy and seems to have breadcrumbs around the crust and makes it even more crispy toward the crust. Sauce tastes good. Cheese tastes pretty good, too. My only critique is that the sauce to Cheese ratio is a little off. In my opinion, I prefer more sauce to cheese, but still, this is a real good slice.8.1 Upside-down: Really good cook on the dough. Every bite is crispy. Sauce tastes good, just a little to much garlic for my taste, but all and all a very good Upside-down. 8.3

Sold out of regular at lunch time so had to go with a corner Grandma. Very light and fluffy with a mix of shredded Mozz and fresh Mozz. Not a ton of a flavor but a pretty decent slice.

So this was a real surprise! Especially the upside down Sicilian. It was one of the best slices of Sicilian I've ever had, and I've had some of the best in the tri-state area. This was pillowy, towering, fluffy, and sultry. This Sicilian had a rich tomato sauce and a great crispy bottom with great height in the slice. They're proofing their dough perfectly for a rise, crumb, and crisp like that. The generous Parmesan cheese is an added bonus. 8.4 on the Sicilian- unfortunately the reg slice was a basic 6.3- except for the crust. The crust was fantastic! Really crunchy and flavorful with nice char.

Good cheese and sauce. Crust was a little too crisp.

Slice was on the small side sauce a little tangy lots of cheese no flop great crust 6.9 for regular slice of pizza there specialty Pizza’s are way better 1.2 better place has good menu for Italian food

little flop, good tang to sauce, little grease, overall a good slice

Solid slice, they say they have the best crust but I’d just say it’s above average.

Decent slice. I like the crust. Can’t put my finger on it but it was just a bit standard/nothing special. Good slice just nothing that makes it stand out.

Great crust

One of my go-to spots when I’m on Long Island.