Romeo's Famous Pizzeria

Surprisingly good pizza. Very kind workers. Wasn’t expecting too much here but it’s a solid slice. Nothing crazy that you’ll go out of the way for, but if you get a pie of this, you’re set. Cheese was maybeeeee a bit off, but other than that, solid all around. If it was more like a bar pie or more well done with a different oven, it would have potential to be in the big leagues

Super floppy but pretty good especially at 2 am. If the undercarriage could get sured up this would be in the high 7s

Great late late night pizza spot on the island. Sicilian had great flavor. Regular pie could use more sauce. Still good flavor…good crust.

Pretty good drunk pizza, mad cheesy but sauce didn’t have much flavor

almost to zero flop, classic neopolitan

I've been coming here for 25 years on my yearly vacation to Wildwood NJ. I ate all 3 nights here while in town. They have the same pizza maker there as long as I could remember. Very, very consistant with quality! 1. Open every night til 5am with all the late night party people leaving the clubs and bars. 2. (Extra bonus) I had the Sicilian slice to change it up one night and had the eggplant parmesan sandwich another night. 3. I am going to give an equal review score with the legendary Macks pizza in Wildwood. (I came thinking Macks would out-due them but didn't happen!) 4. Slice was a bit smaller than average, but price was not that much, so it matched up. (Excellence in every way) 5. My rating on the slice 8.8 ( currently 2nd highest of all my 70+ ratings) Sicilian 8.2 Eggplant parmesan sandwich 7.9

Cool place, foods great. Plain pizza really good plus they are open after the bars. Speciality slices are really good too

Decent pizza. Good cheese, but nothing mind blowing. Would probably get again.

Romeo’s is the best pizza in Wildwood.

No flop at all, typical bar pizza, but pretty good.

Greasy and slice is kinda bland

Awful. Asked for an XL got a slice that was the size of a Tostino’s Pizza Bite. Cheese fell right off, even Michael Phelp’s would drown in the grease on this. Tastes like this is for Gluten-Free people. Never again.

I gave it a extra few crunch score because it had some good crunch, decent late night slice probably better after a long night of late drinking