Order now on Slice
Order Romeo's Italian American
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
About Romeo's Italian American
82 Yelp Reviews
raulfpizzacrew2/10/21, 10:25 p.m.
*disclaimer we order our pies light cooked* Very good, sauce is on the sweet side but it compliments the cheese very well. Crust is amazing with hot doughy goodness on the inside with still a nice crisp on the outside. Would definitely order again.
robnardone11/11/20, 2:35 a.m.
Cheese Pizza Review featuring Moon Goddess Hot Sauce and DJ Wildman Manny.
26 views•1 like
neil.leone8/22/20, 12:11 a.m.
Frankie, the pie was a vodka sauce pie. The sauce was bland and the pie was cold. On top of that, it was soggy in the middle. Yes, soggy and cold. No crisp. I was expecting so much more. Disappointed doesn’t even start the conversation. Place was busy but a cold pie on a Friday night is not acceptable. Would have loved to review it hot. That’s a review.
chriseats7/7/19, 11:28 p.m.
Very good pizza. Would have given a higher 7 rating if the pizza was a bit more crispy, but the sauce and cheese were absolutely amazing. The crust was pretty good too. Recommend if you are passing by!!
jason.lam6/29/19, 5:07 p.m.
“1 plain, not too crispy.” Wow, I didn’t think this would be as good as it is. Your standard flop on an excellent chewy, airy dough! I love this sweet sauce with its perfect ratio of their tad bit salty cheese. I really like it!! 🍕
daveturner4/15/19, 1:23 a.m.
Very good football style pizza. Could use a bit more on the cook (prefer a crisp), sauce has a very good flavor. No oil from cheese. NY flop, yup. Overall you’ll be happy to eat this pie any night of the week.
fakurpizza11/14/18, 11:08 p.m.
Cheese was a little slidey, sauce was fantastic. However, a little doughy.
bigdickslices10/23/18, 8:06 p.m.
When you ask your child to draw you a slice of pizza, this is exactly what you should get. Romeo's offers an amazing traditional plain slice of pizza. The sauce is great, the cheese is great, it's not too greasy, and the dough is solid. Just overall such a mouthwatering great slice of pizza, and exactly what you could hope for out of Central Jersey pizza.