Romeo's Pizza

Looked amazing and was super excited to try it, but was sadly let down. There was none of that classic sicilian bite to this at all. Hard to explain, but the dough and crust were extremely "dry". The sauce had absolutely no flavor to it. The cheese was good....but meh. As a cash only spot too, had high hopes (any time its cash only, always top notch)

Same amazing taste for 20 years.

Very cheesy and good dough crunchy crust

Good solid spot. I prefer the sicilian over the regular. Either way, one of the better spots in the area.

Nicely cooked, sauce was delicious and with the cheese was a nice combination.

Very good Sicilian slice with a perfectly baked, crispy crust

Had high expectations but it’s average. Maybe it was my pie but the crust was a little tough underneath. The cheese is phenomenal though and the crust is good. Overall, gets the job done but there are better pies, especially in Long Island!

Pretty good stuff