Romeo's Pizza

A football pizza you can always count on!

Plain slice: good undercarriage. Decent tang. Not bad. You morons giving it a 10 makes me want to give a 3 to balance it out but I actually care about small businesses so I will be real (unlike you idiots). 7.2 Bonus Sicilian: good undercarriage. Good crisp. Decent flavor. 7.2 Nice place. Nice people.

Excellent pizza, well balanced sauce and cheese. Great flavor and not too greasy. Bonus cheesesteak review: absolutely awesome. Fresh bread with a generous amount of meat and cheese. Definitely worth traveling for.

Large plain pie. Did a one bite in the truck. Good, not great. Dough/crust, cheese, sauce all score right down the middle for me.

Very tasty slice nice sauce. Worthy of high score.

Staple NY pizza of the local area. Crust was slightly disappointing but the sauce and cheese were decent. Buffalo chicken and chicken parm slices could’ve been better. Wouldn’t drive far to go here but solid football pizza Cheese: 7.6 Buff chicken: 7.1 Chicken Parm 7.2

“1 plain, not too crispy.” Standard flop on a reheated slice. Cardboard flavored crust, not airy or chewy. Too much cheese on top of a very bland sauce. Their spicy chorizo was much more tasty, however their dough needs a lot of work for my liking!

I had to think about this slice for a little bit: the crust...the perfect amount of crunch. The sauce? Nice tang. Cheese? Good ingredients. Something about the cheese to sauce ratio is a little off to me. Not quite an 8 but this might be one of the more surprising slices I’ve had in a while.

Romeos Stuffed Cheesesteak slice! Absolutely delicious! The first bite made me want to eat the entire thing in ONE BITE! highly recommend!

Buffalo chicken bacon ranch. Very tasty slice! Cooked perfectly!

Perfect slice. Nice crunch, mozzarella melted perfectly. Best in town.

No flop, awesome crunch. Very nice sauce and cheese. Frank would approve!

Romeo’s in 33 in Manalapan has by far the best pizza in Manalapan / freehold area. Have been coming here for over 5 years since I moved to Manalapan.

best slice around, nothing better

Favorite pie around!

Let me just start by saying they don’t call me Flacko for nothing. It’s because one bite is all it takes to fill me up. With that being said this slice is so damn good I’m still shoving it down my throat even though I cannot physically stomach any more pizza 9/10

Penne vodka slice, first bite was very impressive and loved the taste. Will most definitely order a full pie of this in the future!!

One bite review on Romeos. Slice had no floppage, spot on from the cheese to the dough. Excellent slice.