Rosario's Pizza

Classic

Just came back from NYC trip where we sampled/reviewed 6 shops in Manhattan/Brooklyn with >8.0-9.3 ratings. For this pie.. Slice had no flop, but crust is doughy, with no crisp or crunch. Sauce is middling, cheese is middling. A tolerable but otherwise underwhelming pizza.

Pleasantly surprised by this slice in an unassuming location. Robust pizza sauce with a great ratio of fresh cheese. Nice firm crust. This is absolutely the type of place where a single slice reheated is better than a whole pie to go. Not much to complain about here other than the crust being about a millimeter or two too thick.

It's a good football pizza but little heavy on the dough thickness. The flavor is good and I'd go back but there is better tasting pizza out there.

Medium pizza. Too cheesy and crust was a little tough.

Really good, one of our favorite local spots!

This is the upside down Pizza, just like a plan pizza but they put the cheese down and then the sauce on top. Little bit of flop, thin pizza, nice crispy crust.