Rosella's Pizzeria

Sauce on the sweeter side, crispy crust, cheese wouldn’t stay put. Decent slice

Had very high hopes. Barely worth eating

Good taste. Definitely a good slice. Wish there was some more crust and a little less flop. Could also be crunchier. Definitely not “Downtowns favorite pizza” but not bad. 7.8

Not bad, but not good. Not crispy, not a lot of flavor, just ok. Grandma slice had a strong oregano tang, again not great.

Major New York flop on both of the slices. The sauce is sweet, as it reminds me of Prince Street a little bit.

Elite grandma pie. Sauce is phenomenal. 8.3. All the other pies are probably around a 7.6. So overall, Rosella’s is a 7.9

The grandma’s pizza here is a 9.0. The only problem with the straight cheese slice at Rosella’s is that they use the same sauce that goes into their grandma slice. A good grandma’s slice can handle a sweeter sauce. The straight cheese can’t be too sweet, as there isn’t enough dough to absorb the flavor kick. Other than the too sweet sauce, the cheese is excellent and the dough is very good. Score averages out to a straight 7.

No flop. Sweet sauce was a little strange. Crust wasn’t great. Cheese was pretty good.Dough was bland. Sausage slice was a lot better than the cheese slice.

Light dough with good flavor and really good pepperoni

Zero New York flop, good crust. Nice sauce, good slice of pizza. Looks disgusting.

Solid