The only thing in NYC that will never disappoint 👌🏼
jeff.trimm12/28/19, 8:38 p.m.
A real gem in Penn Station of all places. No flop, slightly sweet but still good sauce, great crust, solid cheese. After visiting 6 different high-rated One Slice destinations in the past 3 days, I have to side with Dave in this and give it a solid 8.0. This is a solid slice that holds up well across the city.
megclassy12/10/19, 7:09 a.m.
Being from NYC, I’m always unimpressed by a large majority of pizza here. However, tried this on a whim and was beyond pleasantly surprised. Great sauce, perfect amount of cheese, excellent crust. I could’ve eaten an entire pie in one sitting. DO IT.
marquist12/10/19, 12:17 a.m.
A little soggy, I prefer more crunch. Awesome sauce. Cheese was a tid bit greasy. Overall really good.
dave091111/28/19, 5:06 p.m.
This was somehow better than the Rose’s I remember that I would get while drunk back in the day / thought was mediocre. Good crisp, no flop, great cheese, a little too greasy and sauce could use more tang but all around solid slice
philyg-man11/18/19, 5:44 p.m.
Excellent Slice! Good Sauce to Cheese ratio Crispy crust Very fresh
steven.d11/17/19, 10:28 a.m.
Unless you see specialty pie put out avoid but the regular cheese moves quickly and is much fresher. Sauce sweet, crust thin and crisp, all the right things for a very good slice, even if you’re not a drunk Passenger heading home.
andrew.smedberg11/4/19, 9:29 p.m.
Make no mistake about it, this pizza is the real deal. There’s a reason this place is always packed. The sauce is the perfect balance between sweet and tang, not too saucy and not too cheesy, solid crust. Not much else you can say it’s just a very solid slice and is worth traveling for.
asf571610/26/19, 6:05 p.m.
Really solid slice. Hardly any flop to be found. Pretty tasty blend too. Enjoyed it.
ben.neidigh10/10/19, 4:43 p.m.
Wasn’t quite as fresh as I’d like. Great sauce. Not much of a flop.