I don’t understand the other 16 reviews about this pizza but if anyone who has lived and eaten at the best pizza spots in the four boroughs, Rosie’s is a secret gem that people who don’t appreciate pizza overlook one of the best spots in the country perfect dough, oven char, mozzarella flavoring, and those pepperoni are to die for
ryan.rutherford10/17/21, 3:18 a.m.
🏖BEST OF THE BEACH ALERT🏖 Don’t expect to stroll off the street and grab a slice here; they have very specific hours and a tight ordering window before they are sold out for the day. Closed on Mondays & Tuesdays and done every night by 8pm (7pm on Sundays); it’s not that easy to get yourself a pie at this joint. Self-proclaimed Artisan (hand-crafted) pizza makers, their ingredients are super fresh and delicious. All pies are prepared well done, with fantastic thin & crispy dough and a substantial char on the thicker but light & airy crust. With the wonderfully fresh mozzarella and sliced garlic, the pie looks and feels more like a Margherita pizza. The milled tomatoes in the sauce are bursting with flavor, accentuated by the fresh cut basil and extra virgin olive oil bringing all of the outstanding ingredients together cohesively into a tantalizingly terrific pizza. If the crust were significantly thinner and tasted less burnt, this pie could easily slide into the vaunted 9s. But as it is, this is one of the best pies you’ll find at the Jersey Shore and is well worth traveling from just about anywhere to get a taste.
chris.kazianis9/24/21, 11:49 p.m.
2!d time here. Been to most of the 9’s in NYC. This is def in the 9’s. One of the best crusts ever!
john.s59/24/21, 7:29 a.m.
Very good ingredients, a little too cooked but willing to try it again to see if that’s the norm
marie.martin9/16/21, 3:55 a.m.
I thought it was really good. Outer crust was perfect (I love that char!) but the middle was floppier than I’d hoped. Nice fresh Basil is standard. Ordered at 12:30 on the dot on my way down to Point Pleasant timing it just right for a 1:45 pickup. Seamless if you plan ahead.
smals18/28/21, 5:46 p.m.
Probably the best undercarriage and crust I’ve had. But the cheese and sauce was average. The single bite with basil was the best part of the pizza
kennyd8/28/21, 1:34 a.m.
Great sauce and crust. The only thing holding it from being higher is it’s a little greasy.
kristen.ochs8/23/21, 1:25 p.m.
Does not disappoint! Perfect sauce and amazing crispy crust. Strongly recommend you find a way to get this pizza.
beckem058/22/21, 4:19 a.m.
Best Jersey slice and not even close. Up there with JoB, Brooklyn’s best, and New Haven