We ordered (2) pies First Pie was excellent, second one not as good, major NJ flop. Cheese had an interesting taste (in a good way) maybe parmesan in addition to mozzarella. Followed by olive oil and basil. Crust was very good. Overall Excellent pizza.
ernie.caponegro3/15/20, 6:39 p.m.
Great pie!! In it's own class. Light and crispy, fresh slice. Could easily put away 4-5 slices no problem. Dave get down here and check this out!!
paulie.pizza2/24/20, 1:45 a.m.
This pizza tastes like nothing I have ever had out before. The crust is very light, airy and crunchy. They use the Pizzamaster oven which cooks it great. Sauce is tasty and both types of mozzarella are used. Not salty at all and the ratio of dough, sauce and cheese is perfect. This is art.
thomas.pettengill2/22/20, 12:29 a.m.
Rosie's "grandma style" square pie is the best pizza I have ever had. It's both crispy and chewy at the same time with an almost sourdough like texture. The care and attention to detail the pizzaiola puts into these pies really shines through. Artisanal is a good word for it. I went to John's of Bleeker street the other week and left disappointed in what I received. Pizza is a treat for me, so when I splurge, I really want to get the best. My dissatisfaction left a hole in me, so the next day I went to Rosie's, bought this pie, and ate the whole thing. The hole was filled and I was fully satisfied. You're cheating yourself if you don't try this place.
chris.carroll2/14/20, 11:58 a.m.
This is pizza is next level. In my opinion Rosies is superior to both Rubirosa and Sauce in NYC, two personal favorites.
michael.benti2/13/20, 5:15 p.m.
Light crust, crispy, delicious sauce! One of the best in Jersey!
mel.klng1/6/20, 11:26 p.m.
Awesome pizza. Best eaten right out of the oven. Great crust, quality ingredients. A must stop for Dave. A New York guy who finally found a spot in NJ 😊
brad.silverstein12/29/19, 7:55 p.m.
Very good slice, fresh mozz, good char. Check this place out!
im_joesmith12/22/19, 6:35 p.m.
Incredible crust, great flavor and bake. The best pizza i’ve ever had!
kepmo11/23/19, 5:07 p.m.
Square pie is where it’s at. Round is good too but not on the level of the square. It is the best pizza in ocean and Monmouth county
lennoll110/5/19, 4:43 p.m.
Really good pie. Crust is light and tender with nice char on edge. Fresh tasting sauce and cheese, good ratio. Only shortcoming: crust a bit undercooked toward center of pie
jrj22398/30/19, 10:10 p.m.
Quality ingredients, flavor out of this world, texture spot on. I can go on and on. Had a small amount of grease due to pepperoni, but that’s to be expected. Absolutely thrilled to have found this place.
halfapizzashark8/24/19, 10:13 p.m.
First of the Owners are stand up guys really nice people. 2nd of all best freshest ingredients used awesome place thin crispy crust great pepperoni very fresh mootz! I’m giving it a 10 to even out level up some of these terrible reviews place is great please try it !
travelincharlie8/22/19, 10:51 p.m.
Greasiest plain pie I’ve ever seen, no slices after lunch, and a 50 minute wait. No thanks. Used to be solid. Not so much now
paul.delorenzo8/16/19, 4:27 p.m.
It’s a very good pie. It will compete with any other top slice out there. But to much flop and sauce just misses the mark and could use a kick. Otherwise it’s totally worth going to Rosie’s
rachellee8/14/19, 7:51 p.m.
Fresh, but greasy and floppy. Taste was great. If it had more crisp would deff be a 9
jdgrabber8/8/19, 10:32 p.m.
Best thin style pizza I’ve tried to date. We came to the shore and I checked the highest rated pizza places and this is where I ended up. The reviews here aren’t exaggerated. This pizza is phenomenal. Sauce, cheese and crust are superb. Go out of your way to stop here you won’t regret it.