Excellent pie. We did curbside pick because #FuckCorona. Super thin and delicious. Solid pie.
jordan.albright11/27/20, 5:13 p.m.
What a pleasant surprise. The sauce is perfect, the crunch and the thinness of the slice Is remarkable. For $13 this is the best pound for pound slice I’ve ever had
mikeyeggs9/9/20, 9:56 p.m.
This was a damn good slice. Cooked well done and crispy. It’s a very thin slice so I could probably polish off an entire pie on my own.
phillip.miller8/9/20, 12:08 a.m.
We’ve been Catfished boys!!! From the pic she looks like a 8-9 but once you meet her face to face she’s a 5.7 at best. Crust is thin and cooked perfectly but it all goes down hill after that. Sauce is basic and the pie has almost No flavor.
bigapplefamily8/4/20, 11:11 p.m.
A solid pie! Sauce is a bit too tangy for my taste but altogether a real good pie.
gowanis.king8/2/20, 11:50 p.m.
Very crispy, good crust, zero flop. Not greasy. Lack of seasoning? I wanted to add salt. Still reasonably tasty.
trynagrabasliceofza7/25/20, 12:38 a.m.
Spectacular pie. Thin crust with a nice char. Every pie is well done which makes for a beautiful undercarriage. Delicious sauce, basil adds a nice bite. 8.3. Kinda wanna go higher but that was my immediate thought. Also, not reviewing it here but buff chick pizza was the best I’ve ever had. That’s a review.
jrzanyc5/3/20, 6:10 a.m.
Ok..... Quarantine Style Review... Grab & Go.. I grabbed whatever was available and gave it a shot. Since I’m Staten Island norm and raised I figured since Denino’s had an hour wait it was the perfect time to try it out and I was beyond impressed. Any of my Staten islanders who know Joe and Pats then just call Round Pie it’s stunt double! Great thin crust with nice char. The sauce had a great taste and the cheese was high quality and the touch of basil was the perfect compliment. The only thing I can say is that there could of been a little more sauce or cheese, it was a tad bit dry. But overall it was fantastic! Knocking on 9’s door with an 8.9 great job!
mayorblueberryjerry4/15/20, 11:50 p.m.
This is there meat lover which is good . Had there regular pie when they opened and it was very crispy but had some good flavor
joenj4/1/20, 6:16 a.m.
Round Pie great job had pie earlier today phenomenal edition to the area very busy place great service. If you Live near this is a must try. This pizza is to die for. Good luck to them, although I don’t think they need it. I would drive 1 hour for this pizza And as for the reviewers below 👇🏻👇🏻 complete BS!
cody.sachs3/21/20, 11:56 p.m.
Had both the arugula pie and signature round pie. Arugula was better than the signature pie. Nothing special. Thing and crispy that’s about it