mikey.giglio12/13/22, 8:39 a.m.
Trash , there is way better pizza spots in matawan !!!! Dough taste like cardboard
sixeightharry9/16/22, 7:48 p.m.
Signature Pie is really good. Delicious sauce. Very crispy. Wings are excellent also.
peetsza8/8/21, 1:11 a.m.
Ok! That’s what’s left from 2 pies. Thin crust with a good crunch to it though not charred. The sauce was very good plum sauce with some strong savory flavor to it. The cheese is very good and blends well with the crust and cheese. Thin crunchy which is really good. Overall, very tasty pizza that I’d go past all others in the area to get. Hence the 8.5 score.
pizzalive4/13/21, 11:47 p.m.
Super Thin Super Crispy Sauce is a bit flat. Definitely worth another try.
lennoll13/5/21, 1:12 a.m.
It’s a work of art! An absolutely beautiful pie, with taste and feel that almost lives up to the view. Crust just a tad too thin and crunchy for perfection, and sauce could use some zip.
jordan.albright11/27/20, 5:13 p.m.
What a pleasant surprise. The sauce is perfect, the crunch and the thinness of the slice Is remarkable. For $13 this is the best pound for pound slice I’ve ever had
mikeyeggs9/9/20, 9:56 p.m.
This was a damn good slice. Cooked well done and crispy. It’s a very thin slice so I could probably polish off an entire pie on my own.
phillip.miller8/9/20, 12:08 a.m.
We’ve been Catfished boys!!! From the pic she looks like a 8-9 but once you meet her face to face she’s a 5.7 at best. Crust is thin and cooked perfectly but it all goes down hill after that. Sauce is basic and the pie has almost No flavor.
bigapplefamily8/4/20, 11:11 p.m.
A solid pie! Sauce is a bit too tangy for my taste but altogether a real good pie.
gowanis.king8/2/20, 11:50 p.m.
Very crispy, good crust, zero flop. Not greasy. Lack of seasoning? I wanted to add salt. Still reasonably tasty.
trynagrabasliceofza7/25/20, 12:38 a.m.
Spectacular pie. Thin crust with a nice char. Every pie is well done which makes for a beautiful undercarriage. Delicious sauce, basil adds a nice bite. 8.3. Kinda wanna go higher but that was my immediate thought. Also, not reviewing it here but buff chick pizza was the best I’ve ever had. That’s a review.
jrzanyc5/3/20, 6:10 a.m.
Ok..... Quarantine Style Review... Grab & Go.. I grabbed whatever was available and gave it a shot. Since I’m Staten Island norm and raised I figured since Denino’s had an hour wait it was the perfect time to try it out and I was beyond impressed. Any of my Staten islanders who know Joe and Pats then just call Round Pie it’s stunt double! Great thin crust with nice char. The sauce had a great taste and the cheese was high quality and the touch of basil was the perfect compliment. The only thing I can say is that there could of been a little more sauce or cheese, it was a tad bit dry. But overall it was fantastic! Knocking on 9’s door with an 8.9 great job!
petezerria5/1/20, 11:18 p.m.
Excellent pie. We did curbside pick because #FuckCorona. Super thin and delicious. Solid pie.
mayorblueberryjerry4/15/20, 11:50 p.m.
This is there meat lover which is good . Had there regular pie when they opened and it was very crispy but had some good flavor
joenj4/1/20, 6:16 a.m.
Round Pie great job had pie earlier today phenomenal edition to the area very busy place great service. If you Live near this is a must try. This pizza is to die for. Good luck to them, although I don’t think they need it. I would drive 1 hour for this pizza And as for the reviewers below 👇🏻👇🏻 complete BS!