Nice and thin great taste. Perfect crunch
john anthony.grimaldi3/7/20, 9:56 p.m.
Tangy.. awesome dough, cute counter girl (adds .5 to score)
patrieek3/1/20, 1:37 a.m.
Perfect, crispy crust. Crunchy bite. Tangy, delicious sauce. Might be on the low side with the score, but im going with Michael Irvin DA BIG 88
robbysports2/17/20, 2:29 p.m.
Been getting great reviews so needed to try for myself... Great pizza, NY pizza
pizzageneral2/3/20, 11:57 p.m.
Special piece of work here.. Only trying places that are suppose to score well.. this is a combination of two of Staten Islands Best.. Deninos & Joe N Pats.. it’s a unique blend of both pies.. crust a combination of both.. sauce like Joe N Pats.. Cheese like Deninos.. Sick!! They did a phenomenal job!!! Sauce 9.1.. Cheese 9.1.. Crust 8.8.. Construction 8.9.. Overall Score 8.9
fatguyfootball2/1/20, 12:34 a.m.
Very good....might be best on Staten Island ...my score my be low @ 8.6.....probably 8.9
megclassy1/8/20, 11:46 p.m.
This is my 5th time ordering from Round Pie. This pizza is KILLER. It is consistently excellent, the sauce is SO GOOD and tangy. The crust is always crunchy and thin, and the cheese is great. Honestly there aren’t many slices this good in all of NYC. It is so worth it, give it a try!
marquist12/12/19, 6:26 a.m.
Really like the crunch. Sauce is delicious and lots of it. Crust isn’t too thick. Solid slice.
simon.krugly9/14/19, 11:22 p.m.
Review for Old Bridge location as it isn’t on the app. Paper thin. Sauce has a very good tase and very little oil from the cheese. Dough is coated with something from the bottom that gives it a little extra crunch. Best local pizza no doubt.
deliveryboy909/8/19, 12:43 a.m.
Thin crispy crust with a nice char to it the EVOO gives a nice fruitiness to the pie and complements the sauce and I love the fresh basil & Parmesan ....good quality ingredients and a great pie overall!
christopher.donohue7/24/19, 6:16 p.m.
Don’t worry, my review is solely based on the plain slice, but recommend the others as well. One of the best around! So damn good!
daveyc6/21/19, 7:12 p.m.
I ordered the ‘round’ pie pie and boy was I happy. A bit thicker than Joe & Pats with a different taste. No Staten Island flop and the crust had a nice crunch. Sauce and cheese were on point. Will be back to this place soon. Thats a review.
kevin.price6/18/19, 12:32 a.m.
Really nice thin crust sauce is out of this world only the cheese leaves me wanting a little more
duncan.lundy6/3/19, 9:08 p.m.
Another thin, crispy crust pizza here on SI, similar to some of the bar pies except a little bigger. The regular pizza is simple but it has a lot of flavor, sauce is slightly sweet, and crust is perfect. The “round pie” is a little more complex with extra grated cheese and fresh basil on top. I wish this style would make it out to Long Island
paulie_pizza5/10/19, 1:33 a.m.
Very thin and crispy. Sauce and cheese are very good. Fresh. Cornmeal on the bottom is great as well.
denise.casey5/7/19, 7:59 a.m.
Thin crispy crust, tangy sauce, just the right amount of cheese 🙌🏽