14,137 views•1,498 likes
gerard.pellegrini7/6/20, 7:05 p.m.
Great looking slice, very crisp but not enough sauce, not nearly enough flavor
patrick.moccia5/9/20, 11:13 p.m.
Tried a margherita pie along with our regular pie order tonight. It was excellent! Slightly better then the regular pie in my opinion, but both are great! Keep up the good work! 🍕👍
chris.magnuson4/21/20, 7:17 p.m.
Have only gotten slices. Today decided to get a 12” pie but it was made into a large pie by accident. No complaint here. The pie as a whole kicks butt. Delicious
paulievee3/18/20, 11:27 p.m.
I always feel like round pie is as if Joe and Pat's and Denino's had a baby. Great pizza. Crispy, tangy, thin. Exactly what a nyc pizza should be. Definitely in the top places on Staten Island.
pizzaqueen073/18/20, 12:51 a.m.
Second favorite spot on the island. The round pie is delicious, sauce is perfect, crust is perfect. Can’t complain about anything. The real winner is their white pie. Extremely underrated. I have to get both every time I go.
carl.christian3/15/20, 6:06 a.m.
Solid 8.4 on the regular slice, sauce is in point and the crust is crispy with no staten flop. But for the pepperoni slice Gotta go 8.7, u can’t go wrong with the little pepperoni cups that capture the pepperoni grease. SOLID
vincentguttilla3/15/20, 2:29 a.m.
Solid slice good crisp tangy really good pizza in this neighborhood
scott.drexler3/14/20, 3:25 p.m.
Pizza was really good! Had a nice crunch, no flop and an good combination of sauce and cheese. Pepperoni made it better!
pizzadoc.jv3/10/20, 2:02 a.m.
I agree with the pre here, 7.8 is a fair score. Without his review, I would probably go 8.1 here. Very tangy. The sauce is much more present here vs Old Bridge NJ. Contents of the slice from Old Bridge flow and work well together. This is a very good slice...but for sure a touch more salty and overpowered by the sauce. If I never had the Old Bridge slice, I would have been very happy with this one. However, I have something to compare it to and Old Bridge puts together a better pie.
23 views•1 like
john anthony.grimaldi3/7/20, 9:56 p.m.
Tangy.. awesome dough, cute counter girl (adds .5 to score)
patrieek3/1/20, 1:37 a.m.
Perfect, crispy crust. Crunchy bite. Tangy, delicious sauce. Might be on the low side with the score, but im going with Michael Irvin DA BIG 88
robbysports2/17/20, 2:29 p.m.
Been getting great reviews so needed to try for myself... Great pizza, NY pizza
pizzageneral2/3/20, 11:57 p.m.
Special piece of work here.. Only trying places that are suppose to score well.. this is a combination of two of Staten Islands Best.. Deninos & Joe N Pats.. it’s a unique blend of both pies.. crust a combination of both.. sauce like Joe N Pats.. Cheese like Deninos.. Sick!! They did a phenomenal job!!! Sauce 9.1.. Cheese 9.1.. Crust 8.8.. Construction 8.9.. Overall Score 8.9
fatguyfootball2/1/20, 12:34 a.m.
Very good....might be best on Staten Island ...my score my be low @ 8.6.....probably 8.9
megclassy1/8/20, 11:46 p.m.
This is my 5th time ordering from Round Pie. This pizza is KILLER. It is consistently excellent, the sauce is SO GOOD and tangy. The crust is always crunchy and thin, and the cheese is great. Honestly there aren’t many slices this good in all of NYC. It is so worth it, give it a try!
marquist12/12/19, 6:26 a.m.
Really like the crunch. Sauce is delicious and lots of it. Crust isn’t too thick. Solid slice.