Pizza was nothing great. Thought it would be better based off other reviews. Slice had a major flop with lots of grease. Cheese stuck to the plate and fell apart as I was eating it. Crust was the best part. I don’t think I’d come back here.
mr.mozzerella5/9/21, 8:59 p.m.
Served very warm in 3-4 minutes with no Closter Crisp and a heavy Jerzee flop. First Bite Score: 5.4 The sauce is almost invisible and has a slight tang with no major flavor profile. The mozzarella is mediocre with zero salinity or chew and there is way too much of it. The dough is pedestrian, overworked and undercooked. The undercarriage looks nice but is floppy with decent flavor. Sub Score: 5.6 SAUCE: needs to be thinner and better seasoned, also an even distribution would be better MOZZARELLA: either improve the quality of apply less to the slice. The heat can’t penetrate the cheese blanket so it leaves the dough par-cooked DOUGH: try to work it less when making the pies, the flavor is very good it’s just very dense. Summary: thinner sauce, better cheese or less of it coupled with a lighter dough can bring this to the high 6.0’s. There is too much missing to shoot for anything higher. Final Score...
hvpizzaking2/5/21, 9:03 p.m.
Ahhhh broke my promise but hard good things about this place and I was in the area. As you can tell I was disappointed. Great undercarriage, and the dough recipe and cheese were good. Hardly any sauce and more grease. More sauce could have boosted the score.
michaelcorleone1/24/21, 5:42 p.m.
Nice bite! Dough is slightly dry but the sweetness of the sauce and cheese make up for it.
steve.deangelo9/19/20, 1:16 a.m.
Heard some good things so tried it out. It was OK, thought would be better. Crust needs work and could use more sauce. Decent taste.
nas.dafku1/22/20, 10:27 p.m.
Very good cheese, excellent dough. Good combination and solid slice!
jason.timochko8/9/19, 3:30 p.m.
Crust has a nice crisp. Everything looks fresh but the pizza had ZERO flavor.
zeebs5/25/19, 12:45 a.m.
Very late entry on this review. Classic football pizza, but a very good one. Not much flop. Chewy dough, good tangy sauce, great cheese. This place has been around since 1962ish. There’s a movie about the place on Amazon Video. Been coming here since I was a three year old. Hometown score could be higher, but I think this is an honest score. Dave’s gotta make a visit sometime. Side note, LOVE the Sicilian slice here too.
mike.pete110/10/18, 11:23 p.m.
Crispy crust, good amount of cheese, and they keep garlic on every table 👌🏽
willy.delrio9/1/18, 10:12 p.m.
This pizza was very average and if you are in a mood for a slice you could not go wrong by going here