Rustoni's Pizza

The Margherita depicted, while not very traditional, was a sharp departure from the rest of their pies. The marinara sauce is very sweet on the Margherita and made up for the sweetness lacking in such little basil. The regular pies are greasy with cheap cheese. Regular pizza sauce isn't terrible, dough was OK. 5.3 for their standard.

Classic, reliable football pizza

Amazing, great customer service, great sauce taste, Brooklyn slice was great

Solid slice. Great sauce. (Score based off of cheese slice)

Zero flop. Great sauce. Let’s go! Good Jersey slice.

Basic basic football pizza. Nothing to go out of the way for. Cheese and sauce very plain. Little crisp.

Average “Strip Mall Pizza” we get when we’re in a pinch visiting my in-laws. Better than the local alternatives. Sauce is ok-a lot of flavor; but tries too hard. Average cheese. Decent crust.

Really good grandma pizza. Good sauce, good crust.

Good pizza . Very tasty.

Not their best effort. I’ve eaten their pizza many times and this isn’t up to par with how it usually is. Crispy but a bit greasy and over cooked.