Sal & Carmine's Pizza

Been wanting to try forever. Went in with zero expectations and damn this is a good classic slice. I’m tired of the new school spots, this is pizza to me.

Forgot to take a pic. Pepperoni was 8.1

Good, but very filling and super greasy. Decent street pizza.

Some solid, no-bullshit slices. An Upper West Side institution and a great neighborhood spot.

Hella good

Cheese has some potential but is completing run over with a tractor trailer by the sweetness of the sauce, which must have more sugar in it than a red velvet cake. Gross. Really just barely edible. Crust was ok, which brings it just to a weak 6.0. Never again, I’m good.

Very good slice. The flavor of the sauce and dough are what single-handedly carried the score. If it was SLIGHTLY less oily, doughy and cheesy and we got ourselves a good ballgame.

Great sauce!

2nd stop on my upper west side pizza walk. Place is definitely an old school favorite of the neighborhood. Pizza was pretty average to me. Very greasy and a little overdone. Had thicker crust than a normal NY slice. Also a tad overpriced for what you’re getting.

Classic NYC slice, great crust and a little greasy.

Unreal crunch, but the amount of cheese and sweet sauce just aren’t my style. The crunch of this slice makes it great! Worth a try

If you don’t like Sal & Carmine’s, you probably just don’t like NY-style pizza. It’s a classic slice with a slightly sweeter sauce. In one word - EXCELLENT!

Large slices, tangy sweet sauce, very good ratio sauce to cheese. Very good pizza, will buy again and again. Crispy crust, slight flop, if baked 2-3 minutes more for a more well done finish, its an easy 8.4

First slice in the city. Chose this joint because it was the highest rated near my hotel. Fresh out of the oven... Delightful

Not in the 7’s. Undercarriage is good, but the thickness is like two Bros. Awful service, the guy tried to give me my slice cold

Very hot, very greasy, very good :)

Cheese slice: probably one of the best NY slices I’ve had; cheese is very good, melted almost to perfection; sauce is very good, maybe just a tad sweeter than I would’ve liked, but definitely very good, nice crunch, but not really any char; not much flop; dough is decent, difficult to describe, but better than average; overall, again a very good slice at $3 (no credit card minimum btw)