luke.sherlockgh11/26/21, 6:28 p.m.
Great pizza but the sauce is very sweet and I’m a salty guy more than sweet very thin too which is good
sagarrana11/20/21, 7:43 p.m.
If you love crispy crust and easy to eat thin pizza, this is your spot!
kenny.terrell11/17/21, 5:48 p.m.
Good crisp to it, however the sauce the cheese ration was a bit off. The cheese was definitely lacking
brandon.perman11/16/21, 4:08 a.m.
The sauce is everything on this. Amazing flavorful slice
8 views•0 likes
timgoodwinone11/15/21, 5:56 p.m.
Cheese side was amazing. Pepperoni was definitely spicy. Sauce was great
sheldon.sookoo11/13/21, 2:36 a.m.
Good but very Oily , a little Overrated by Dave . the dough is like rubber . That's the difference between NYC dough and rest of the world
km01111/10/21, 12:24 p.m.
I went here directly after having Frank Pepe's, so I can directly compare the two better than most. Sally's arrives to your table a comically large box, and it surprisingly fills the entire thing! The pizza itself is extremely thin with quite a bit of flop and very little crunch. The flavor of the sauce is very unique and enjoyable, but there is nowhere near enough cheese on this pie! Maybe I had too high of expectations after watching Dave's review and seeing the 8.8 rating on the app, but I have to say that Sally's actually let me down quite a bit. Maybe I got a dud, but I have this near the bottom of the New Haven options.
stevepizzareviews11/7/21, 12:23 a.m.
IMO this is over hyped. Super flop and crust is charred. Too much sauce, not much cheese. This comes in third after Modern, and Frank’s in 1st.
19 views•0 likes
pmw10/24/21, 11:43 p.m.
Crispy char without burn flavor. Not sure how they are able to pull this off. But it’s great. Sauce lovers pie here. I really enjoyed it.
josh.hellapizza10/23/21, 8:48 p.m.
Unreal, great crunch, some flop but gotta give leeway bc of the big slices. Angelos in Manhattan tops this.
christopher.aquilino10/22/21, 11:11 p.m.
This is for Sally's Stamford, CT. Will delete this review and transfer it to right location whenever they update the app to include Sally's Stamford. Not sure how the One Bite app updates with new locations. Been waiting for this one. Sally's Apizza! Almost in separable from Frank Pepe's. So I have that comparison in my mind. Only other apizza I've had is Brewport. Welp, the crispiness of this pie (The Mootz) is beaten by few. I think Johnny's in Mount Vernon, NY best it from what I've had so far. But it's in an elite class crunchy crispiness. I do think some people overrate that factor in a crust since Barstool but it's undeniably top tier. Now it's not an airy crust. But it's delicate and not chewy. And I don't think think you should go any more well done or charred than this. Pepe's barely seems charred by comparison. I'm not sure that's better though. The New Haven will kill me but I think for lots of people/your average persin, the char is almost too much here. Being cooked this much also dries out the pie a bit. Again, Barstool folks taking after Portnoy would praise how there's no "grease" and no flop. True. But I'm not so sure everyone wants a pie this devoid oil/wetness. Nobody wants a tasteless, greasy mess, yeah. But fat carries flavor. And olive oil is good on a pie. I'm loving the cheese to sauce ratio here. Saucy pie, like my favorites. And no end crust. It's such a well engineered and good looking pie. I'm out of order with how I usually format these reviews. But for a rundown of things I haven't mentioned: The sauce is chunky bits of tomatoes not runny or watery. What was only okay about that was that it's a neutral, umami tasting sauce when I'd've preferred a naturally sweet sauce to balance out the the charred flavor. That's something I really like about Pepe's Tomato Pie and Margarita Pie: natural sweetness balanced out by the charred bitterness and sharpness of the pecorino. Because of this I think most people coming from quintessential has oven NY style will prefer Pepe's pies overall. But Sally's makes a great Mootz pie. Better than Frank Pepe's. For me though, this isn't my ideal pizza, so I can't give it the 9+.